Skip to content
Free shipping on all orders over $150
Now offering free shipping on orders over $150!

Nostalgic Candy

Filters

$
$
Halloween Witches Brew Rock Candy Sticks 6 Pack Sold out
$2.19 - $2.19
$2.19
$2.19
$2.19 - $2.19
$2.19

Halloween Witches Brew Rock Candy Sticks 6 Pack

Out of stock

Halloween Witches Brew Rock Candy Sticks are sold in a pack of six. Each stick contains crystallized sugar in Halloween-themed colors such as green...

View full details
$2.19 - $2.19
$2.19
$2.19
$2.19 - $2.19
$2.19
Sold out
Sold out
$6.72 - $6.72
$6.72
$6.72
$6.72 - $6.72
$6.72

Hammond's Mint Chip Marshmallows 4oz

Out of stock

Hammond's Mint Chip Marshmallows come in a 4oz bag (20 pieces) featuring soft mint marshmallows with chocolate chips sprinkled on top. Hammond's Ca...

View full details
$6.72 - $6.72
$6.72
$6.72
$6.72 - $6.72
$6.72
Sold out
Hammond's Peanut Butter Pillows 6oz Sold out
$9.86 - $9.86
$9.86
$9.86
$9.86 - $9.86
$9.86

Hammond's Peanut Butter Pillows 6oz

Out of stock

Hammond's Peanut Butter Pillows come in a 6oz bag with a thin candy shell and crunchy peanut butter inside. However, this isn’t a peanut butter cup...

View full details
$9.86 - $9.86
$9.86
$9.86
$9.86 - $9.86
$9.86
Sold out
Hayden Valley Chocolate Covered Pretzels with Red Nonpareils 1lb Sold out
$8.49 - $8.49
$8.49
$8.49
$8.49 - $8.49
$8.49

Hayden Valley Chocolate Covered Pretzels with Red Nonpareils 1lb

Out of stock

$8.49 - $8.49
$8.49
$8.49
$8.49 - $8.49
$8.49
Sold out
Hayden Valley White Yogurt Covered Heart Pretzels with Red Nonpareils 1lb
Sold out
$8.49 - $8.49
$8.49
$8.49
$8.49 - $8.49
$8.49

Hayden Valley White Yogurt Covered Heart Pretzels with Red Nonpareils 1lb

Out of stock

$8.49 - $8.49
$8.49
$8.49
$8.49 - $8.49
$8.49
Sold out
Ice Blue Mint Squares 1lb
Sold out
$6.39 - $6.39
$6.39
$6.39
$6.39 - $6.39
$6.39

Ice Blue Mint Squares 1lb

Out of stock

Ice Blue Mint Squares 1lbs.

$6.39 - $6.39
$6.39
$6.39
$6.39 - $6.39
$6.39
Sold out
Jelly Belly Black Licorice Scottie Dogs 6oz Bag
Sold out
$5.19 - $5.19
$5.19
$5.19
$5.19 - $5.19
$5.19

Jelly Belly Black Licorice Scottie Dogs 6oz Bag

Out of stock

$5.19 - $5.19
$5.19
$5.19
$5.19 - $5.19
$5.19
Sold out
Jelly Belly Candy Corn 1lb
Sold out
$8.59 - $8.59
$8.59
$8.59
$8.59 - $8.59
$8.59

Jelly Belly Candy Corn 1lb

Out of stock

Jelly Belly Candy Corn comes in a 1lb bag, presenting a full pound of classic tri-color candy corn pieces. This candy reflects the smooth texture ...

View full details
$8.59 - $8.59
$8.59
$8.59
$8.59 - $8.59
$8.59
Sold out
Jelly Belly Candy Corn 3 oz Bag
Sold out
$3.49 - $3.49
$3.49
$3.49
$3.49 - $3.49
$3.49

Jelly Belly Candy Corn 3 oz Bag

Out of stock

This American classic, Jelly Belly Candy Corn, boasts a creamy vanilla flavor and smooth texture. It comes in a convenient 3oz bag for easy snackin...

View full details
$3.49 - $3.49
$3.49
$3.49
$3.49 - $3.49
$3.49
Sold out
Jelly Belly Harry Poter Butterbeer 1 oz Bag 24 ct
Sold out
$28.79 - $28.79
$28.79
$28.79
$28.79 - $28.79
$28.79

Jelly Belly Harry Poter Butterbeer 1 oz Bag 24 ct

Out of stock

Experience the magical flavor of Butterbeer with Jelly Belly Harry Potter Butterbeer jelly beans. These golden beans capture the sweet, butterscotc...

View full details
$28.79 - $28.79
$28.79
$28.79
$28.79 - $28.79
$28.79
Sold out
Jelly Belly Licorice 7.5 oz bag
Sold out
$7.49 - $7.49
$7.49
$7.49
$7.49 - $7.49
$7.49

Jelly Belly Licorice 7.5 oz bag

Out of stock

Jelly Belly Licorice jelly beans come in a 7.5oz gift bag, delivering authentic flavor made with real licorice. These black jelly beans offer a cla...

View full details
$7.49 - $7.49
$7.49
$7.49
$7.49 - $7.49
$7.49
Sold out
Jelly Belly Licorice Bridge Mix 1lb
Sold out
$11.19 - $11.19
$11.19
$11.19
$11.19 - $11.19
$11.19

Jelly Belly Licorice Bridge Mix 1lb

Out of stock

Experience a world of licorice flavor with Jelly Belly Licorice Bridge Mix in a 1lb resealable bag. This mix includes a variety of licorice cand...

View full details
$11.19 - $11.19
$11.19
$11.19
$11.19 - $11.19
$11.19
Sold out
Jelly Belly Licorice Bridge Mix 6.75 oz Bag
Sold out
$7.49 - $7.49
$7.49
$7.49
$7.49 - $7.49
$7.49

Jelly Belly Licorice Bridge Mix 6.75 oz Bag

Out of stock

Jelly Belly Licorice Bridge Mix comes in a 6.75oz bag, offering a variety of licorice-based candies blended into one assortment. This candy highli...

View full details
$7.49 - $7.49
$7.49
$7.49
$7.49 - $7.49
$7.49
Sold out
Jelly Belly Scottie Dogs Black Licorice 1 lb
Sold out
$9.29 - $9.29
$9.29
$9.29
$9.29 - $9.29
$9.29

Jelly Belly Scottie Dogs Black Licorice 1 lb

Out of stock

Jelly Belly Scottie Dogs Black Licorice come in a 1lb resealable bag for long-lasting licorice enjoyment. These adorable Scottie dog-shaped can...

View full details
$9.29 - $9.29
$9.29
$9.29
$9.29 - $9.29
$9.29
Sold out
Jelly Belly Scottie Dogs Strawberry Licorice 1 lb
Sold out
$9.29 - $9.29
$9.29
$9.29
$9.29 - $9.29
$9.29

Jelly Belly Scottie Dogs Strawberry Licorice 1 lb

Out of stock

Jelly Belly Strawberry Licorice Scottie Dogs come in a 1lb bag, offering strawberry-flavored licorice pieces shaped like small Scottie dogs. This ...

View full details
$9.29 - $9.29
$9.29
$9.29
$9.29 - $9.29
$9.29
Sold out
Jelly Belly Strawberry Licorice Scottie Dogs 6oz Bag
Sold out
$5.19 - $5.19
$5.19
$5.19
$5.19 - $5.19
$5.19

Jelly Belly Strawberry Licorice Scottie Dogs 6oz Bag

Out of stock

Jelly Belly Strawberry Licorice Scottie Dogs offer a playful twist on classic licorice with a 6oz bag filled with adorable dog shapes. Enjoy str...

View full details
$5.19 - $5.19
$5.19
$5.19
$5.19 - $5.19
$5.19
Sold out
Kargher Mini Christmas Nonpareils 1lb
Sold out
$13.09 - $13.09
$13.09
$13.09
$13.09 - $13.09
$13.09

Kargher Mini Christmas Nonpareils 1lb

Out of stock

This year, try our Mini Christmas Nonpareils! These delightful, colorful candies are a perfect addition to your holiday celebrations. Each piece is...

View full details
$13.09 - $13.09
$13.09
$13.09
$13.09 - $13.09
$13.09
Sold out
King Leo Crushed Peppermint 1lb
Sold out
$7.19 - $7.19
$7.19
$7.19
$7.19 - $7.19
$7.19

King Leo Crushed Peppermint 1lb

Out of stock

Enhance your culinary creations with King Leo Crushed Peppermint, now available in a convenient 1lb bag. This premium crushed peppermint adds a ...

View full details
$7.19 - $7.19
$7.19
$7.19
$7.19 - $7.19
$7.19
Sold out
King Leo Soft Peppermint Puffs 1lb
Sold out
$6.19 - $6.19
$6.19
$6.19
$6.19 - $6.19
$6.19

King Leo Soft Peppermint Puffs 1lb

Out of stock

Experience King Leo Soft Peppermint Puffs, now available in a generous 1lb bag. These classic soft puffs are crafted with care, delivering a smooth...

View full details
$6.19 - $6.19
$6.19
$6.19
$6.19 - $6.19
$6.19
Sold out
King Leo Soft Peppermint Puffs Christmas 14oz Bag
Sold out
$3.69 - $3.69
$3.69
$3.69
$3.69 - $3.69
$3.69

King Leo Soft Peppermint Puffs Christmas 14oz Bag

Out of stock

$3.69 - $3.69
$3.69
$3.69
$3.69 - $3.69
$3.69
Sold out
King Leo Soft Peppermint Puffs Christmas Wrapped 1lb
Sold out
$4.69 - $4.69
$4.69
$4.69
$4.69 - $4.69
$4.69

King Leo Soft Peppermint Puffs Christmas Wrapped 1lb

Out of stock

$4.69 - $4.69
$4.69
$4.69
$4.69 - $4.69
$4.69
Sold out
Sold out
$6.99 - $6.99
$6.99
$6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
$6.99

King Leo Soft Peppermint Sticks 11.5oz Box

Out of stock

$6.99 - $6.99
$6.99
$6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
$6.99
Sold out
King Leo Soft Peppermint Sticks 5oz Bag
Sold out
$7.89 - $7.89
$7.89
$7.89
$7.89 - $7.89
$7.89

King Leo Soft Peppermint Sticks 5oz Bag

Out of stock

Enjoy the classic taste of King Leo Soft Peppermint Sticks! This 1lb bag is filled with individually wrapped peppermint candy sticks. Each stick d...

View full details
$7.89 - $7.89
$7.89
$7.89
$7.89 - $7.89
$7.89
Sold out
King Leo Soft Peppermint Sticks Giant 3.5oz Bag
Sold out
$1.39 - $1.39
$1.39
$1.39
$1.39 - $1.39
$1.39

King Leo Soft Peppermint Sticks Giant 3.5oz Bag

Out of stock

$1.39 - $1.39
$1.39
$1.39
$1.39 - $1.39
$1.39
Sold out

Nostalgic Candy

When it comes to Nostalgic Candy, we offer all the brands and flavors you’ve come to love and enjoy! So if you’re looking for something sweet from your childhood, then chances are we have what you’re looking for, and more!

That’s right; at Candy Retailer, we offer all the classics from Albanese Milk Chocolate Triple Dipped Malt Balls, Anise Squares, Fruit Discs, Starlights Mints, Wrapped Citrus Slices, Astro Pops, Atkinson Black Cow Chocolate, Honeycombed Peanuts, Coconut Long Boys, Slo Pokes, Atomic Fireballs, Runk’s B.B. Bats, Boston Baked Beans, Boyer Cups, Cella's Chocolate Covered Cherries, Rock Candy On A Stick, Rock Candy, and so much more!

So as you can see, when it comes to nostalgic candy, we have so many options to select from, including hard-to-find candy classics, penny candy, and bulk candy by the pound! That said, pick up some of your all-time favorite candies and enjoy them the way you always have! Available for nationwide shipping, so order today!