Skip to content
Free Shipping Orders $150+
Free Shipping Orders $150+

Nostalgic Candy

Filters

Original price $6.99 - Original price $6.99
Original price $6.99
$6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
Current price $6.99

Atkinson Black Cow 1lb

Only 6 left!

Atkinson Black Cow chocolate candy is a unique and delicious treat that is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. Made with creamy milk chocolate and a ...

View full details
Original price $6.99 - Original price $6.99
Original price $6.99
$6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
Current price $6.99
Original price $29.69 - Original price $29.69
Original price $29.69
$29.69
$29.69 - $29.69
Current price $29.69

Atkinson Black Cow Chocolate Caramel 24ct Box

Only 4 left!

Atkinson Black Cow Chocolate Caramel candy is a delectable treat that combines the richness of milk chocolate with the creamy, smooth texture of ca...

View full details
Original price $29.69 - Original price $29.69
Original price $29.69
$29.69
$29.69 - $29.69
Current price $29.69
Original price $21.09 - Original price $21.09
Original price $21.09
$21.09
$21.09 - $21.09
Current price $21.09

Atkinson Long Boys Coconut 130ct Tub

Only 4 left!

Atkinson Coconut Long Boys is a delicious and rare treat that is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. These candies are made with a creamy, smooth coc...

View full details
Original price $21.09 - Original price $21.09
Original price $21.09
$21.09
$21.09 - $21.09
Current price $21.09
Original price $7.39 - Original price $7.39
Original price $7.39
$7.39
$7.39 - $7.39
Current price $7.39

Atkinson Long Boys Coconut 1lb

Only 17 left!

Atkinson Long Boys Coconut is a type of individually wrapped nostalgic candy that comes in a 1lb resealable bag. These candies have a sweet coconut...

View full details
Original price $7.39 - Original price $7.39
Original price $7.39
$7.39
$7.39 - $7.39
Current price $7.39
Original price $6.99 - Original price $6.99
Original price $6.99
$6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
Current price $6.99

Atkinson Long Boys Coconut Juniors Bite Size 1lb

Only 20 left!

Atkinson Coconut Long Boys Juniors Bite Size is a delicious and convenient treat that is perfect for any occasion. These bite-sized candies are mad...

View full details
Original price $6.99 - Original price $6.99
Original price $6.99
$6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
Current price $6.99
Original price $6.39 - Original price $6.39
Original price $6.39
$6.39
$6.39 - $6.39
Current price $6.39

Atkinson Red and White Mint Twists 1lb

Only 10 left!

Atkinson Red and White Mint Twists are a type of hard candy that comes in a 1lb bag and are individually wrapped for convenience. These classic hol...

View full details
Original price $6.39 - Original price $6.39
Original price $6.39
$6.39
$6.39 - $6.39
Current price $6.39
Original price $7.99 - Original price $7.99
Original price $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
Current price $7.99

Atkinson Red N Green Mint Twists 1lb

in stock

Atkinson Red N Green Mint Twists are a type of hard candy that comes in a 1lb bag. These festive and colorful candies have a fresh, cool peppermint...

View full details
Original price $7.99 - Original price $7.99
Original price $7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
Current price $7.99
Original price $4.79 - Original price $4.79
Original price $4.79
$4.79
$4.79 - $4.79
Current price $4.79

Atkinson Sugar Free Peanut Butter Bars 3.75oz Bag

Only 12 left!

Atkinson Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Bars are a type of candy that provides a delicious and guilt-free treat for anyone looking for a tasty candy opti...

View full details
Original price $4.79 - Original price $4.79
Original price $4.79
$4.79
$4.79 - $4.79
Current price $4.79
Original price $17.79 - Original price $17.79
Original price $17.79
$17.79
$17.79 - $17.79
Current price $17.79

Atkinsons Black Cow Bite Size 160pc Tub

Only 11 left!

Atkinson’s Black Cow Bite Size candies are a classic chocolate caramel treat that comes in a 160-piece tub. These delicious candies are a little bi...

View full details
Original price $17.79 - Original price $17.79
Original price $17.79
$17.79
$17.79 - $17.79
Current price $17.79
Original price $10.29 - Original price $10.29
Original price $10.29
$10.29
$10.29 - $10.29
Current price $10.29

Atkinsons Coconut Long Boys 48ct

Only 1 left!

Atkinsons Coconut Long Boys is a 48-count box of nostalgic chewy candy. These classic candies have a rich and creamy coconut flavor and a satisfyin...

View full details
Original price $10.29 - Original price $10.29
Original price $10.29
$10.29
$10.29 - $10.29
Current price $10.29
Original price $19.09 - Original price $19.09
Original price $19.09
$19.09
$19.09 - $19.09
Current price $19.09

Atkinsons Crunchy Peanut Butter Bars 0.21oz 160pc Tub

Only 11 left!

Atkinsons Crunchy Peanut Butter Bars come in a 160-piece tub, featuring individually wrapped bite-sized bars made with peanut butter and other hand...

View full details
Original price $19.09 - Original price $19.09
Original price $19.09
$19.09
$19.09 - $19.09
Current price $19.09
Original price $28.19 - Original price $28.19
Original price $28.19
$28.19
$28.19 - $28.19
Current price $28.19

Atkinsons Crunchy Peanut Butter Bars 0.34oz 160pc Tub

Only 6 left!

Atkinsons Tubs Crunchy Peanut Butter Bars are a bulk-sized tub of 160 classic candy bars. These satisfying treats feature a rich and creamy peanut ...

View full details
Original price $28.19 - Original price $28.19
Original price $28.19
$28.19
$28.19 - $28.19
Current price $28.19
Original price $13.49 - Original price $13.49
Original price $13.49
$13.49
$13.49 - $13.49
Current price $13.49

Atkinsons Jumbo Mint Sticks 36ct

Only 2 left!

Atkinson's Jumbo Mint Sticks are a type of candy made by the Atkinson Candy Company. They are individually wrapped mint sticks that are red and whi...

View full details
Original price $13.49 - Original price $13.49
Original price $13.49
$13.49
$13.49 - $13.49
Current price $13.49
Original price $3.29 - Original price $3.29
Original price $3.29
$3.29
$3.29 - $3.29
Current price $3.29

Atkinsons Mint Twists Red and White Peppermint Sticks 3.5oz

in stock

Refresh your senses with Mint Twists Red and White Peppermint Sticks, now in a delightful 3.5oz package. These classic peppermint sticks, adorn...

View full details
Original price $3.29 - Original price $3.29
Original price $3.29
$3.29
$3.29 - $3.29
Current price $3.29
Original price $14.99 - Original price $14.99
Original price $14.99
$14.99
$14.99 - $14.99
Current price $14.99

Atkinsons Rainbow Sticks 36ct

Only 1 left!

Atkinsons Rainbow Sticks are a fun and colorful candy that come in a 36-count box. These classic candies have a unique and playful rainbow design w...

View full details
Original price $14.99 - Original price $14.99
Original price $14.99
$14.99
$14.99 - $14.99
Current price $14.99
Original price $11.89 - Original price $11.89
Original price $11.89
$11.89
$11.89 - $11.89
Current price $11.89

Black Jack Chewing Gum 20ct Box

Only 6 left!

Black Jack Chewing Gum 20/5pks.

Original price $11.89 - Original price $11.89
Original price $11.89
$11.89
$11.89 - $11.89
Current price $11.89
Original price $11.29 - Original price $11.29
Original price $11.29
$11.29
$11.29 - $11.29
Current price $11.29

Boston Baked Beans 24ct Box

Only 18 left!

Produced by Ferrara Pan Candy Company, embrace your inner child and treat yourself to Boston Baked Beans! These beans aren’t actually beans, instea...

View full details
Original price $11.29 - Original price $11.29
Original price $11.29
$11.29
$11.29 - $11.29
Current price $11.29
Original price $2.79 - Original price $2.79
Original price $2.79
$2.79
$2.79 - $2.79
Current price $2.79

Boston Baked Beans 4.3oz Box

Only 6 left!

Attention all candy lovers! Are you looking to add some sweetness to your movie nights at home? If so, Candy Retailer now has Boston Baked Beans ca...

View full details
Original price $2.79 - Original price $2.79
Original price $2.79
$2.79
$2.79 - $2.79
Current price $2.79
Original price $29.89 - Original price $29.89
Original price $29.89
$29.89
$29.89 - $29.89
Current price $29.89

Boyer Mallo Cups 24ct

Only 14 left!

Since 1936, Mallo Cups have become an American classic. Created by the Boyer Candy Company, this candy’s delicious combination of milk chocolate an...

View full details
Original price $29.89 - Original price $29.89
Original price $29.89
$29.89
$29.89 - $29.89
Current price $29.89
Original price $5.79 - Original price $5.79
Original price $5.79
$5.79
$5.79 - $5.79
Current price $5.79

Brachs Cinnamon Imperials 12oz Bag

Only 16 left!

Brach’s Cinnamon Imperials have been popular since the early 1900s, continuing the brand’s long legacy of bold-flavored sweets that stand the test...

View full details
Original price $5.79 - Original price $5.79
Original price $5.79
$5.79
$5.79 - $5.79
Current price $5.79
Original price $7.39 - Original price $7.39
Original price $7.39
$7.39
$7.39 - $7.39
Current price $7.39

Brachs Holiday Peppermint Nougats 11oz Bag

in stock

Brach’s Holiday Peppermint Nougats have been part of holiday celebrations for generations, carrying the same creamy texture and refreshing mint fla...

View full details
Original price $7.39 - Original price $7.39
Original price $7.39
$7.39
$7.39 - $7.39
Current price $7.39
Original price $5.79 - Original price $5.79
Original price $5.79
$5.79
$5.79 - $5.79
Current price $5.79

Brachs Holiday Spicettes 10oz Bag

in stock

Brach’s Holiday Spicettes have been a winter candy tradition since the mid-1900s, continuing the brand’s reputation for festive holiday sweets. Thi...

View full details
Original price $5.79 - Original price $5.79
Original price $5.79
$5.79
$5.79 - $5.79
Current price $5.79
Original price $39.39 - Original price $39.39
Original price $39.39
$39.39
$39.39 - $39.39
Current price $39.39

Brachs Mini Candy Canes 260ct Tub

Only 1 left!

Brach’s Mini Candy Canes have been a holiday favorite since the 1920s, when the company began producing peppermint candies that quickly became part...

View full details
Original price $39.39 - Original price $39.39
Original price $39.39
$39.39
$39.39 - $39.39
Current price $39.39
Original price $4.39 - Original price $4.39
Original price $4.39
$4.39
$4.39 - $4.39
Current price $4.39

Brachs Peppermint Crushed Candy Cane 10oz Bag

in stock

Brach's Peppermint Crushed Candy Canes come in a 10oz bag, making it easy to add peppermint candy to seasonal treats. Pre-crushed candy eliminates ...

View full details
Original price $4.39 - Original price $4.39
Original price $4.39
$4.39
$4.39 - $4.39
Current price $4.39

Nostalgic Candy

Some candies never go out of style. From old-fashioned penny candy to the classic sweets we grew up enjoying, nostalgic candy has a way of reminding us of our favorite childhood treats. At Candy Retailer, we offer a wide selection of traditional candies, including hard-to-find favorites that have been enjoyed for generations.

Remember visiting your neighborhood candy store and choosing your favorites from jars filled with colorful sweets? That tradition is still alive today! Our collection includes Atomic Fireballs, Boston Baked Beans, Slo Pokes, B.B. Bats, Black Cow Chocolate, Cella's Chocolate Covered Cherries, Starlight Mints, Rock Candy, and many other classic favorites.

Whether you're looking for a childhood favorite, putting together your own assortment of old-fashioned sweets, or shopping for candy by the pound, we have plenty of options to choose from. Browse our nostalgic candy collection and rediscover the brands and flavors you remember, all available for nationwide shipping from Candy Retailer.