Skip to content
Free shipping on all orders over $150
Now offering free shipping on orders over $150!

Nostalgic Candy

Filters

$
$
Atkinson Crushed Red and White Mint Twists for Baking 8oz Sold out
$3.89 - $3.89
$3.89
$3.89
$3.89 - $3.89
$3.89

Atkinson Crushed Red and White Mint Twists for Baking 8oz

Out of stock

Take your creative baking to another level with the vibrant flavor and color of Atkinson Crushed Red and White Mint Twists, now available in an 8oz...

View full details
$3.89 - $3.89
$3.89
$3.89
$3.89 - $3.89
$3.89
Sold out
Atkinson Honeycombed Peanuts 1lb Sold out
$5.49 - $5.49
$5.49
$5.49
$5.49 - $5.49
$5.49

Atkinson Honeycombed Peanuts 1lb

Out of stock

Atkinson Honeycombed Peanuts are a type of hard candy that comes in a 1lb bag and are individually wrapped for convenience. These candies have a un...

View full details
$5.49 - $5.49
$5.49
$5.49
$5.49 - $5.49
$5.49
Sold out
Sold out
$4.89 - $4.89
$4.89
$4.89
$4.89 - $4.89
$4.89

Atkinson Peanut Butter Eyeballs 1lb

Out of stock

Atkinson Peanut Butter Eyeballs are a fun and spooky Halloween candy that come in a 1lb bag, individually wrapped for convenience. These candies ha...

View full details
$4.89 - $4.89
$4.89
$4.89
$4.89 - $4.89
$4.89
Sold out
Sold out
$5.39 - $5.39
$5.39
$5.39
$5.39 - $5.39
$5.39

Atkinson Peanut Butter Skeleton Bones 1lb

Out of stock

Atkinson Peanut Butter Skeleton Bones are a fun and festive Halloween candy that comes in a 1lb bag. These candies have a delicious peanut butter f...

View full details
$5.39 - $5.39
$5.39
$5.39
$5.39 - $5.39
$5.39
Sold out
Sold out
$5.59 - $5.59
$5.59
$5.59
$5.59 - $5.59
$5.59

Atkinson Pumpkin Spice Caramel 1lb

Out of stock

Atkinson Pumpkin Spice Caramel is a 1lb bag of delicious handcrafted caramels. These soft and chewy caramels are the perfect treat to welcome the f...

View full details
$5.59 - $5.59
$5.59
$5.59
$5.59 - $5.59
$5.59
Sold out
Atkinson Red and White Mint Twists 1lb
Sold out
$5.39 - $5.39
$5.39
$5.39
$5.39 - $5.39
$5.39

Atkinson Red and White Mint Twists 1lb

Out of stock

Atkinson Red and White Mint Twists are a type of hard candy that comes in a 1lb bag and are individually wrapped for convenience. These classic hol...

View full details
$5.39 - $5.39
$5.39
$5.39
$5.39 - $5.39
$5.39
Sold out
Atkinson Red and White Mint Twists 5oz Bag
Sold out
$2.69 - $2.69
$2.69
$2.69
$2.69 - $2.69
$2.69

Atkinson Red and White Mint Twists 5oz Bag

Out of stock

Enjoy Atkinson Red and White Mint Twists, now in a convenient 5oz bag. These iconic mint candies feature a striking red and white twist design, del...

View full details
$2.69 - $2.69
$2.69
$2.69
$2.69 - $2.69
$2.69
Sold out
Atkinson Red and White Mint Twists Flow Wrap 1lb
Sold out
$5.39 - $5.39
$5.39
$5.39
$5.39 - $5.39
$5.39

Atkinson Red and White Mint Twists Flow Wrap 1lb

Out of stock

Atkinson Red and White Mint Twists are handmade using natural ingredients and premium peppermint oil, delivering a bold and refreshing flavor. Pack...

View full details
$5.39 - $5.39
$5.39
$5.39
$5.39 - $5.39
$5.39
Sold out
Atkinson Red and White Peppermint Sticks Stocking Stuffer
Sold out
$2.59 - $2.59
$2.59
$2.59
$2.59 - $2.59
$2.59

Atkinson Red and White Peppermint Sticks Stocking Stuffer

Out of stock

Atkinson Red and White Peppermint Sticks are the perfect stocking stuffer, offering a festive blend of taste and tradition in each piece. This c...

View full details
$2.59 - $2.59
$2.59
$2.59
$2.59 - $2.59
$2.59
Sold out
Atkinson Wintergreen Mint Twists 1lb
Sold out
$5.39 - $5.39
$5.39
$5.39
$5.39 - $5.39
$5.39

Atkinson Wintergreen Mint Twists 1lb

Out of stock

Atkinson Wintergreen Mint Twists are a refreshing and fun twist-shaped candy that comes in a 1lb bag. Made with high-quality ingredients, they're p...

View full details
$5.39 - $5.39
$5.39
$5.39
$5.39 - $5.39
$5.39
Sold out
Atkinsons Mint Twists Red and White Peppermint Sticks 3.5oz
Sold out
$2.09 - $2.09
$2.09
$2.09
$2.09 - $2.09
$2.09

Atkinsons Mint Twists Red and White Peppermint Sticks 3.5oz

Out of stock

Refresh your senses with Mint Twists Red and White Peppermint Sticks, now in a delightful 3.5oz package. These classic peppermint sticks, adorn...

View full details
$2.09 - $2.09
$2.09
$2.09
$2.09 - $2.09
$2.09
Sold out
Atkinsons Peanut Butter Bars 36ct
Sold out
$12.39 - $12.39
$12.39
$12.39
$12.39 - $12.39
$12.39

Atkinsons Peanut Butter Bars 36ct

Out of stock

Get ready to indulge in the delicious and satisfying taste of Atkinson’s Peanut Butter Bars! This 36-count box of classic candy bars is bursting wi...

View full details
$12.39 - $12.39
$12.39
$12.39
$12.39 - $12.39
$12.39
Sold out
Atkinsons Red White and Green Giant 2lb Peppermint Stick
Sold out
$11.89 - $11.89
$11.89
$11.89
$11.89 - $11.89
$11.89

Atkinsons Red White and Green Giant 2lb Peppermint Stick

Out of stock

$11.89 - $11.89
$11.89
$11.89
$11.89 - $11.89
$11.89
Sold out
Atomic Fireball 240ct Jar
Sold out
$39.69 - $39.69
$39.69
$39.69
$39.69 - $39.69
$39.69

Atomic Fireball 240ct Jar

Out of stock

Atomic Fireball comes in a 240-count, 4lb jar filled with individually wrapped cinnamon-flavored hard candies. Known as the original spicy candy, e...

View full details
$39.69 - $39.69
$39.69
$39.69
$39.69 - $39.69
$39.69
Sold out
Atomic Fireballs 1lb
Sold out
$4.59 - $4.59
$4.59
$4.59
$4.59 - $4.59
$4.59

Atomic Fireballs 1lb

Out of stock

Adults and children alike have been treating themselves to Atomic Fireballs since 1954! Produced by Ferrara Pan Candy Company, these candies have a...

View full details
$4.59 - $4.59
$4.59
$4.59
$4.59 - $4.59
$4.59
Sold out
B.B. Bats Assorted Taffy 100ct
Sold out
$13.59 - $13.59
$13.59
$13.59
$13.59 - $13.59
$13.59

B.B. Bats Assorted Taffy 100ct

Out of stock

B.B. Bats Assorted Taffy is a mouth-watering assortment of classic taffy candy that's known for its flavor and quality. Each box contains 100 indiv...

View full details
$13.59 - $13.59
$13.59
$13.59
$13.59 - $13.59
$13.59
Sold out
Bee Christmas Airheads Gingerbread House Kit 26oz
Sold out
$10.79 - $10.79
$10.79
$10.79
$10.79 - $10.79
$10.79

Bee Christmas Airheads Gingerbread House Kit 26oz

Out of stock

$10.79 - $10.79
$10.79
$10.79
$10.79 - $10.79
$10.79
Sold out
Bee Christmas Chocolate Chip Cookie Cottage Kit 14oz
Sold out
$7.29 - $7.29
$7.29
$7.29
$7.29 - $7.29
$7.29

Bee Christmas Chocolate Chip Cookie Cottage Kit 14oz

Out of stock

$7.29 - $7.29
$7.29
$7.29
$7.29 - $7.29
$7.29
Sold out
Bee Christmas Chocolate Chip Cookie Cottage Kit 26oz
Sold out
$10.79 - $10.79
$10.79
$10.79
$10.79 - $10.79
$10.79

Bee Christmas Chocolate Chip Cookie Cottage Kit 26oz

Out of stock

Unleash your creativity this holiday season with the Bee Christmas Chocolate Chip Cookie Cottage Kit, a delightful 26oz package designed to bring f...

View full details
$10.79 - $10.79
$10.79
$10.79
$10.79 - $10.79
$10.79
Sold out
Bee Christmas Gingerbread Cabin Kit 26oz
Sold out
$11.09 - $11.09
$11.09
$11.09
$11.09 - $11.09
$11.09

Bee Christmas Gingerbread Cabin Kit 26oz

Out of stock

$11.09 - $11.09
$11.09
$11.09
$11.09 - $11.09
$11.09
Sold out
Bee Christmas Gingerbread House Kit 14oz
Sold out
$6.99 - $6.99
$6.99
$6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
$6.99

Bee Christmas Gingerbread House Kit 14oz

Out of stock

$6.99 - $6.99
$6.99
$6.99
$6.99 - $6.99
$6.99
Sold out
Bee Christmas Gingerbread Mini Village Kit 26oz
Sold out
$11.09 - $11.09
$11.09
$11.09
$11.09 - $11.09
$11.09

Bee Christmas Gingerbread Mini Village Kit 26oz

Out of stock

$11.09 - $11.09
$11.09
$11.09
$11.09 - $11.09
$11.09
Sold out
Bee Christmas Gingerbread Train Kit 25oz
Sold out
$11.09 - $11.09
$11.09
$11.09
$11.09 - $11.09
$11.09

Bee Christmas Gingerbread Train Kit 25oz

Out of stock

$11.09 - $11.09
$11.09
$11.09
$11.09 - $11.09
$11.09
Sold out
Bee Christmas Jelly Belly Gingerbread House Kit 26oz
Sold out
$10.79 - $10.79
$10.79
$10.79
$10.79 - $10.79
$10.79

Bee Christmas Jelly Belly Gingerbread House Kit 26oz

Out of stock

$10.79 - $10.79
$10.79
$10.79
$10.79 - $10.79
$10.79
Sold out

Nostalgic Candy

When it comes to Nostalgic Candy, we offer all the brands and flavors you’ve come to love and enjoy! So if you’re looking for something sweet from your childhood, then chances are we have what you’re looking for, and more!

That’s right; at Candy Retailer, we offer all the classics from Albanese Milk Chocolate Triple Dipped Malt Balls, Anise Squares, Fruit Discs, Starlights Mints, Wrapped Citrus Slices, Astro Pops, Atkinson Black Cow Chocolate, Honeycombed Peanuts, Coconut Long Boys, Slo Pokes, Atomic Fireballs, Runk’s B.B. Bats, Boston Baked Beans, Boyer Cups, Cella's Chocolate Covered Cherries, Rock Candy On A Stick, Rock Candy, and so much more!

So as you can see, when it comes to nostalgic candy, we have so many options to select from, including hard-to-find candy classics, penny candy, and bulk candy by the pound! That said, pick up some of your all-time favorite candies and enjoy them the way you always have! Available for nationwide shipping, so order today!