Skip to content
Free shipping on all orders over $150
Now offering free shipping on orders over $150!

Peanut Butter Candy

Filters

$
$
Reeses Fast Break 18ct Box Sold out
$31.89 - $31.89
$31.89
$31.89
$31.89 - $31.89
$31.89

Reeses Fast Break 18ct Box

Out of stock

Get a satisfying break with Reese's Fast Break! This 18-count box includes individually wrapped bars featuring creamy peanut butter and chewy nouga...

View full details
$31.89 - $31.89
$31.89
$31.89
$31.89 - $31.89
$31.89
Sold out
Reeses Fast Break King 18ct Box Sold out
$41.89 - $41.89
$41.89
$41.89
$41.89 - $41.89
$41.89

Reeses Fast Break King 18ct Box

Out of stock

Take a break with Reese’s Fast Break King Size candy bars. This 18-count box features the classic combo of creamy peanut butter, chewy nougat, and ...

View full details
$41.89 - $41.89
$41.89
$41.89
$41.89 - $41.89
$41.89
Sold out
Reeses Halloween Peanut Butter Skeletons 9.1oz Bag Sold out
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99

Reeses Halloween Peanut Butter Skeletons 9.1oz Bag

Out of stock

$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
$8.99
$8.99 - $8.99
$8.99
Sold out
Reeses Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup with Marshmallow Flavored Creme 9.35oz Bag Sold out
$8.29 - $8.29
$8.29
$8.29
$8.29 - $8.29
$8.29

Reeses Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup with Marshmallow Flavored Creme 9.35oz Bag

Out of stock

Reese's Mallow-Top Peanut Butter Cups combine classic peanut butter flavor with a fluffy marshmallow-flavored creme. This 9.35oz bag is perfect for...

View full details
$8.29 - $8.29
$8.29
$8.29
$8.29 - $8.29
$8.29
Sold out
Reeses Milk Thins 3.1oz Bag
Sold out
$3.89 - $3.89
$3.89
$3.89
$3.89 - $3.89
$3.89

Reeses Milk Thins 3.1oz Bag

Out of stock

$3.89 - $3.89
$3.89
$3.89
$3.89 - $3.89
$3.89
Sold out
Reeses Minis 10.5oz Bag
Sold out
$9.49 - $9.49
$9.49
$9.49
$9.49 - $9.49
$9.49

Reeses Minis 10.5oz Bag

Out of stock

$9.49 - $9.49
$9.49
$9.49
$9.49 - $9.49
$9.49
Sold out
Reeses Minis 7.6oz Bag
Sold out
$6.59 - $6.59
$6.59
$6.59
$6.59 - $6.59
$6.59

Reeses Minis 7.6oz Bag

Out of stock

$6.59 - $6.59
$6.59
$6.59
$6.59 - $6.59
$6.59
Sold out
Reeses Minis King 16ct Box
Sold out
$30.49 - $30.49
$30.49
$30.49
$30.49 - $30.49
$30.49

Reeses Minis King 16ct Box

Out of stock

$30.49 - $30.49
$30.49
$30.49
$30.49 - $30.49
$30.49
Sold out
Reeses Mrs Freshleys Cupcake 6ct Box
Sold out
$13.29 - $13.29
$13.29
$13.29
$13.29 - $13.29
$13.29

Reeses Mrs Freshleys Cupcake 6ct Box

Out of stock

ReeseSticks - King Size 24CT Box

$13.29 - $13.29
$13.29
$13.29
$13.29 - $13.29
$13.29
Sold out
Reeses Nutrageous King 18ct Box
Sold out
$41.89 - $41.89
$41.89
$41.89
$41.89 - $41.89
$41.89

Reeses Nutrageous King 18ct Box

Out of stock

Discover the ultimate chocolate and peanut butter experience with Reese's Nutrageous bars. Available now at Candy Retailer, these bars feature rich...

View full details
$41.89 - $41.89
$41.89
$41.89
$41.89 - $41.89
$41.89
Sold out
Reeses Nutrageous Reg 18ct Box
Sold out
$31.89 - $31.89
$31.89
$31.89
$31.89 - $31.89
$31.89

Reeses Nutrageous Reg 18ct Box

Out of stock

Reese’s Nutrageous Bars are made in the United States by The Hershey Company. First introduced in 1994, this candy bar is known for combining mult...

View full details
$31.89 - $31.89
$31.89
$31.89
$31.89 - $31.89
$31.89
Sold out
Reeses Outrageous King 18ct Box
Sold out
$34.29 - $34.29
$34.29
$34.29
$34.29 - $34.29
$34.29

Reeses Outrageous King 18ct Box

Out of stock

$34.29 - $34.29
$34.29
$34.29
$34.29 - $34.29
$34.29
Sold out
Reeses Outrageous Reg 18ct Box
Sold out
$21.29 - $21.29
$21.29
$21.29
$21.29 - $21.29
$21.29

Reeses Outrageous Reg 18ct Box

Out of stock

$21.29 - $21.29
$21.29
$21.29
$21.29 - $21.29
$21.29
Sold out
Reeses Peanut Butter Cups 36ct Box
Sold out
$44.49 - $44.49
$44.49
$44.49
$44.49 - $44.49
$44.49

Reeses Peanut Butter Cups 36ct Box

Out of stock

Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups is a gluten-free, certified kosher candy made in the United States by The Hershey Company. First created in 1928 by H.B....

View full details
$44.49 - $44.49
$44.49
$44.49
$44.49 - $44.49
$44.49
Sold out
Reeses Peanut Butter Cups Miniatures 105ct Box
Sold out
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79

Reeses Peanut Butter Cups Miniatures 105ct Box

Out of stock

Make your day a little sweeter with the Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Miniatures. Made with delicious peanut butter and savory milk chocolate, you will...

View full details
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
$15.79
$15.79 - $15.79
$15.79
Sold out
Reeses Peanut Butter Eggs 36ct Box
Sold out
$34.39 - $34.39
$34.39
$34.39
$34.39 - $34.39
$34.39

Reeses Peanut Butter Eggs 36ct Box

Out of stock

Make your Easter celebrations even sweeter with Reese's Peanut Butter Eggs! These egg-shaped treats are made with delicious milk chocolate and pean...

View full details
$34.39 - $34.39
$34.39
$34.39
$34.39 - $34.39
$34.39
Sold out
Reeses Peanut Butter Eggs King Size 24ct Box
Sold out
$45.59 - $45.59
$45.59
$45.59
$45.59 - $45.59
$45.59

Reeses Peanut Butter Eggs King Size 24ct Box

Out of stock

Produced by The Hershey Company, bring more joy to your Easter celebrations with Reese's Peanut Butter Eggs King Size! Made with savory milk chocol...

View full details
$45.59 - $45.59
$45.59
$45.59
$45.59 - $45.59
$45.59
Sold out
Reeses Peanut Butter Holiday Lights 4.8oz Box
Sold out
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99

Reeses Peanut Butter Holiday Lights 4.8oz Box

Out of stock

$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
$7.99
$7.99 - $7.99
$7.99
Sold out
Reeses Peanut Butter Trees 36ct Box
Sold out
$23.79 - $23.79
$23.79
$23.79
$23.79 - $23.79
$23.79

Reeses Peanut Butter Trees 36ct Box

Out of stock

Make your holiday celebrations even better with Reese's Peanut Butter Trees! Produced by The Hershey Company, these tree-shaped candies are made wi...

View full details
$23.79 - $23.79
$23.79
$23.79
$23.79 - $23.79
$23.79
Sold out
Reeses Peanut Butter Trees Snack Size 9.6oz Bag
Sold out
$8.09 - $8.09
$8.09
$8.09
$8.09 - $8.09
$8.09

Reeses Peanut Butter Trees Snack Size 9.6oz Bag

Out of stock

Reese's Peanut Butter Trees comes in a 9.6-oz snack-size bag. This product features a creamy peanut butter filling coated in smooth milk chocolate,...

View full details
$8.09 - $8.09
$8.09
$8.09
$8.09 - $8.09
$8.09
Sold out
Reeses Pieces 4oz Box
Sold out
$2.69 - $2.69
$2.69
$2.69
$2.69 - $2.69
$2.69

Reeses Pieces 4oz Box

Out of stock

$2.69 - $2.69
$2.69
$2.69
$2.69 - $2.69
$2.69
Sold out
Reeses Pieces 6oz Bag
Sold out
$4.49 - $4.49
$4.49
$4.49
$4.49 - $4.49
$4.49

Reeses Pieces 6oz Bag

Out of stock

$4.49 - $4.49
$4.49
$4.49
$4.49 - $4.49
$4.49
Sold out
Reeses Pieces 9.9oz Bag
Sold out
$8.59 - $8.59
$8.59
$8.59
$8.59 - $8.59
$8.59

Reeses Pieces 9.9oz Bag

Out of stock

$8.59 - $8.59
$8.59
$8.59
$8.59 - $8.59
$8.59
Sold out
Reeses Pieces Carrot 2.2oz Bag
Sold out
$2.89 - $2.89
$2.89
$2.89
$2.89 - $2.89
$2.89

Reeses Pieces Carrot 2.2oz Bag

Out of stock

Reese's Pieces Carrot is a fun Easter twist! This 2.2-ounce carrot-shaped bag is filled with classic Reese's Pieces – the perfect combination of p...

View full details
$2.89 - $2.89
$2.89
$2.89
$2.89 - $2.89
$2.89
Sold out

Peanut Butter Candy

Peanut butter candy is one of the most popular non-fruit candy categories, known for its rich and creamy flavor made from peanuts and sugar. Peanut-based sweets have been produced in the United States since the late 19th century, with peanut butter becoming widely used in candy during the early 20th century as it gained popularity as a food product.

This category includes several candy types, such as peanut butter cups, chewy candies, filled chocolates, and peanut butter hard candies. Peanut butter candy is typically light brown or tan in color and is often paired with chocolate in many products. Here at Candy Retailer, we carry a large selection of peanut butter candy from major brands, including 5th Avenue, Atkinson, M&M’s, Marshas Homemade Buckeyes, Mary Jane, Reese’s, Taffy Delight, and many others!