Skip to content
Free Shipping Orders $150+
Free Shipping Orders $150+

Nostalgic Candy

Filters

Original price $7.89 - Original price $7.89
Original price $7.89
$7.89
$7.89 - $7.89
Current price $7.89

Lemonhead Original 12oz Bag

Only 13 left!

Lemonhead Original comes in a 12oz resealable stand-up bag with an airtight seal designed to keep every piece fresh. Since 1962, this original lemo...

View full details
Original price $7.89 - Original price $7.89
Original price $7.89
$7.89
$7.89 - $7.89
Current price $7.89
Original price $21.09 - Original price $21.09
Original price $21.09
$21.09
$21.09 - $21.09
Current price $21.09

Lemonhead Original 150ct Jar

Only 4 left!

Original Lemonhead balls are a refreshing sour candy made by Ferrara Candy Company. These tangy, delightful little candies come in a 150-count jar ...

View full details
Original price $21.09 - Original price $21.09
Original price $21.09
$21.09
$21.09 - $21.09
Current price $21.09
Original price $11.29 - Original price $11.29
Original price $11.29
$11.29
$11.29 - $11.29
Current price $11.29

Lemonhead Original 24ct Box

in stock

Original Lemonhead candies are a classic, famously-known candy made by Ferrara. These tart and tangy candies are now available in bulk at Candy Ret...

View full details
Original price $11.29 - Original price $11.29
Original price $11.29
$11.29
$11.29 - $11.29
Current price $11.29
Original price $2.69 - Original price $2.69
Original price $2.69
$2.69
$2.69 - $2.69
Current price $2.69

Lemonhead Original 4.5oz Bag

Only 10 left!

Lemonhead Original comes in a 4.5oz single-size bag, perfect for enjoying on the go. Known as the original lemon candy since 1962, these bright yel...

View full details
Original price $2.69 - Original price $2.69
Original price $2.69
$2.69
$2.69 - $2.69
Current price $2.69
Original price $2.69 - Original price $2.69
Original price $2.69
$2.69
$2.69 - $2.69
Current price $2.69

Lemonhead Original 5oz Box

Only 5 left!

Indulge in Original Lemonhead candies made by Ferrara. Now available in convenient 5oz theater-size boxes at Candy Retailer, these tangy, sweet tre...

View full details
Original price $2.69 - Original price $2.69
Original price $2.69
$2.69
$2.69 - $2.69
Current price $2.69
Original price $13.69 - Original price $13.69
Original price $13.69
$13.69
$13.69 - $13.69
Current price $13.69

Marpro Yum Yum Marshmallow Candy Cones 30ct Tub

in stock

This old time favorite marshmallow treat comes in a display tub. 30 individually wrapped marshmallow Yum Yum Cones. “This candy changes with the we...

View full details
Original price $13.69 - Original price $13.69
Original price $13.69
$13.69
$13.69 - $13.69
Current price $13.69
Original price $9.79 - Original price $9.79
Original price $9.79
$9.79
$9.79 - $9.79
Current price $9.79

Marshas Homemade Buckeyes 8oz Tub

Only 4 left!

Marshas Homemade Buckeyes 8oz Tub

Original price $9.79 - Original price $9.79
Original price $9.79
$9.79
$9.79 - $9.79
Current price $9.79
Original price $2.89 - Original price $2.89
Original price $2.89
$2.89
$2.89 - $2.89
Current price $2.89

Melster Circus Peanuts 4oz Bag

Only 14 left!

Melster Circus Peanuts come in a 4oz bag with the traditional orange, banana-flavored marshmallow candies known for their oversized peanut shape. M...

View full details
Original price $2.89 - Original price $2.89
Original price $2.89
$2.89
$2.89 - $2.89
Current price $2.89
Original price $2.69 - Original price $2.69
Original price $2.69
$2.69
$2.69 - $2.69
Current price $2.69

Melster Strawberry Circus Peanuts 4oz Bag

Only 11 left!

Melster Strawberry Circus Peanuts come in a 4oz bag with pink, strawberry-flavored marshmallow candies shaped like oversized peanuts. Made by Impac...

View full details
Original price $2.69 - Original price $2.69
Original price $2.69
$2.69
$2.69 - $2.69
Current price $2.69
Original price $33.49 - Original price $33.49
Original price $33.49
$33.49
$33.49 - $33.49
Current price $33.49

Necco Wafers Assorted 24CT Box

Only 17 left!

Necco Wafers Assorted come in a 24ct box featuring classic wafer rolls with a mix of original flavors. This box is perfect for office jars, gifting...

View full details
Original price $33.49 - Original price $33.49
Original price $33.49
$33.49
$33.49 - $33.49
Current price $33.49
Original price $31.49 - Original price $31.49
Original price $31.49
$31.49
$31.49 - $31.49
Current price $31.49

Necco Wafers Chocolate 24ct Box

Only 10 left!

Necco Wafers Chocolate comes in a 24ct box featuring classic chocolate wafer rolls. This box is perfect for candy bowls, offices, break rooms, and ...

View full details
Original price $31.49 - Original price $31.49
Original price $31.49
$31.49
$31.49 - $31.49
Current price $31.49
Original price $7.69 - Original price $7.69
Original price $7.69
$7.69
$7.69 - $7.69
Current price $7.69

Nuclear Blaze Blasters 1 lb

Only 8 left!

Original price $7.69 - Original price $7.69
Original price $7.69
$7.69
$7.69 - $7.69
Current price $7.69
Original price $4.19 - Original price $4.19
Original price $4.19
$4.19
$4.19 - $4.19
Current price $4.19

Piedmont Peppermint Puffs Wrapped 1lb

Only 17 left!

Piedmont Peppermint Puffs, now available in a 1lb bag, offer a refreshing burst of peppermint flavor in a light, airy candy. These wrapped peppermi...

View full details
Original price $4.19 - Original price $4.19
Original price $4.19
$4.19
$4.19 - $4.19
Current price $4.19
Original price $7.09 - Original price $7.09
Original price $7.09
$7.09
$7.09 - $7.09
Current price $7.09

Primrose Filled Strawberry Buttons 1lb

in stock

Primrose Filled Strawberry Buttons are packaged in a 1lb bag with individually wrapped pieces featuring a sweet strawberry flavor and a creamy fill...

View full details
Original price $7.09 - Original price $7.09
Original price $7.09
$7.09
$7.09 - $7.09
Current price $7.09
Original price $6.49 - Original price $6.49
Original price $6.49
$6.49
$6.49 - $6.49
Current price $6.49

Primrose Gala Mix 1lb

in stock

Try Primrose Gala Mix, now available in a convenient 1lb bag. This premium assortment of candies showcases the best of Primrose's confectionery art...

View full details
Original price $6.49 - Original price $6.49
Original price $6.49
$6.49
$6.49 - $6.49
Current price $6.49
Original price $5.69 - Original price $5.69
Original price $5.69
$5.69
$5.69 - $5.69
Current price $5.69

Primrose Root Beer Barrels 1lb

in stock

Primrose Root Beer Barrels are packaged in a 1lb bag with individually wrapped pieces, delivering the classic taste of rich, creamy root beer. Perf...

View full details
Original price $5.69 - Original price $5.69
Original price $5.69
$5.69
$5.69 - $5.69
Current price $5.69
Original price $20.69 - Original price $20.69
Original price $20.69
$20.69
$20.69 - $20.69
Current price $20.69

Putmans Opera Cream 14oz Box

in stock

Putmans Opera Cream 14oz Box

Original price $20.69 - Original price $20.69
Original price $20.69
$20.69
$20.69 - $20.69
Current price $20.69
Original price $25.79 - Original price $25.79
Original price $25.79
$25.79
$25.79 - $25.79
Current price $25.79

Putmans Opera Cream 28oz Box

Only 13 left!

Indulge in the classic taste of Putman’s Opera Cream, now in a generous 28oz box. Each piece is a delightful blend of rich chocolate and creamy fo...

View full details
Original price $25.79 - Original price $25.79
Original price $25.79
$25.79
$25.79 - $25.79
Current price $25.79
Original price $13.39 - Original price $13.39
Original price $13.39
$13.39
$13.39 - $13.39
Current price $13.39

Putmans Opera Cream 7oz Box

in stock

Putmans Opera Cream 7oz Box

Original price $13.39 - Original price $13.39
Original price $13.39
$13.39
$13.39 - $13.39
Current price $13.39
Original price $37.59 - Original price $37.59
Original price $37.59
$37.59
$37.59 - $37.59
Current price $37.59

Razzles Original Candy 24ct Box

Only 1 left!

Since the 1960s, Razzles Original Candy has been bringing joy to adults and children alike! It has a hard candy shell, gum center, and five fruity ...

View full details
Original price $37.59 - Original price $37.59
Original price $37.59
$37.59
$37.59 - $37.59
Current price $37.59
Original price $30.79 - Original price $30.79
Original price $30.79
$30.79
$30.79 - $30.79
Current price $30.79

Razzles Tropical Candy 24ct Box

Only 6 left!

Escape to a world of tropical flavors with Razzles Tropical Candy in this convenient 24-count box. First a candy, then a gum! Discover the uniqu...

View full details
Original price $30.79 - Original price $30.79
Original price $30.79
$30.79
$30.79 - $30.79
Current price $30.79
Original price $6.29 - Original price $6.29
Original price $6.29
$6.29
$6.29 - $6.29
Current price $6.29

Red Bird Cotton Candy Puffs Wrapped 1lb

Only 13 left!

Original price $6.29 - Original price $6.29
Original price $6.29
$6.29
$6.29 - $6.29
Current price $6.29
Original price $17.69
Original price $17.69 - Original price $17.69
Original price $17.69
Current price $13.49
$13.49 - $13.49
Current price $13.49

Repperts Christmas Dark Chocolate Peppermint Crunch Drops 1Lb

in stock

Original price $17.69
Original price $17.69 - Original price $17.69
Original price $17.69
Current price $13.49
$13.49 - $13.49
Current price $13.49
Save 24% Save %
Original price $7.09 - Original price $7.09
Original price $7.09
$7.09
$7.09 - $7.09
Current price $7.09

Rito Small Conversation Hearts 1lb

in stock

Discover Rito's Small Conversation Hearts, now offered by the pound for all your festive needs. These miniature candies carry on the tradition of s...

View full details
Original price $7.09 - Original price $7.09
Original price $7.09
$7.09
$7.09 - $7.09
Current price $7.09

Nostalgic Candy

Some candies never go out of style. From old-fashioned penny candy to the classic sweets we grew up enjoying, nostalgic candy has a way of reminding us of our favorite childhood treats. At Candy Retailer, we offer a wide selection of traditional candies, including hard-to-find favorites that have been enjoyed for generations.

Remember visiting your neighborhood candy store and choosing your favorites from jars filled with colorful sweets? That tradition is still alive today! Our collection includes Atomic Fireballs, Boston Baked Beans, Slo Pokes, B.B. Bats, Black Cow Chocolate, Cella's Chocolate Covered Cherries, Starlight Mints, Rock Candy, and many other classic favorites.

Whether you're looking for a childhood favorite, putting together your own assortment of old-fashioned sweets, or shopping for candy by the pound, we have plenty of options to choose from. Browse our nostalgic candy collection and rediscover the brands and flavors you remember, all available for nationwide shipping from Candy Retailer.