Skip to content
Free shipping on all orders over $150
Now offering free shipping on orders over $150!

Peanut Butter Candy

Filters

$
$
Atkinson Chick O Stick 160ct Jar
$25.89 - $25.89
$25.89
$25.89
$25.89 - $25.89
$25.89

Atkinson Chick O Stick 160ct Jar

in stock

Atkinson Chick-O-Stick is a nostalgically delicious and hard-to-find candy that is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. These treats are made with a c...

View full details
$25.89 - $25.89
$25.89
$25.89
$25.89 - $25.89
$25.89
Atkinson Chick O Stick Flat 1lb
$6.89 - $6.89
$6.89
$6.89
$6.89 - $6.89
$6.89

Atkinson Chick O Stick Flat 1lb

in stock

Atkinson Chick-O-Stick is a crunchy and creamy candy that combines the flavors of toasted coconut and peanut butter with a smooth chocolate coating...

View full details
$6.89 - $6.89
$6.89
$6.89
$6.89 - $6.89
$6.89
Atkinson Chick O Stick Nugget 160ct Tub
$16.69 - $16.69
$16.69
$16.69
$16.69 - $16.69
$16.69

Atkinson Chick O Stick Nugget 160ct Tub

Only 3 left!

Atkinson Chick-O-Stick Nuggets are bite-sized pieces of crunchy, toasted coconut and peanut butter flavor covered in a layer of creamy, smooth choc...

View full details
$16.69 - $16.69
$16.69
$16.69
$16.69 - $16.69
$16.69
Atkinson Chick O Stick Nugget 1lb
$6.09 - $6.09
$6.09
$6.09
$6.09 - $6.09
$6.09

Atkinson Chick O Stick Nugget 1lb

in stock

The Atkinson Chick-O-Stick Nugget is a snack that is both sweet & salty and has a crunchy texture. It is made with roasted peanuts and coconut,...

View full details
$6.09 - $6.09
$6.09
$6.09
$6.09 - $6.09
$6.09
Atkinson Chick O Stick Wrapped 1lb
$7.69 - $7.69
$7.69
$7.69
$7.69 - $7.69
$7.69

Atkinson Chick O Stick Wrapped 1lb

Only 2 left!

Indulge in the timeless taste of Atkinson Chick-O-Stick, now conveniently wrapped in a 1lb package! These classic confections are a crunchy, peanut...

View full details
$7.69 - $7.69
$7.69
$7.69
$7.69 - $7.69
$7.69
Atkinson Sugar Free Chick O Stick Nuggets 1lb
$12.39 - $12.39
$12.39
$12.39
$12.39 - $12.39
$12.39

Atkinson Sugar Free Chick O Stick Nuggets 1lb

in stock

Atkinson Sugar-Free Chick-O-Stick Nuggets are a guilt-free candy that comes in a 1lb bag. These candies have a delicious coconut flavor and a satis...

View full details
$12.39 - $12.39
$12.39
$12.39
$12.39 - $12.39
$12.39
Atkinson Sugar Free Peanut Butter Bars 3.75oz Bag
$4.79 - $4.79
$4.79
$4.79
$4.79 - $4.79
$4.79

Atkinson Sugar Free Peanut Butter Bars 3.75oz Bag

in stock

Atkinson Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Bars are a type of candy that provides a delicious and guilt-free treat for anyone looking for a tasty candy opti...

View full details
$4.79 - $4.79
$4.79
$4.79
$4.79 - $4.79
$4.79
Atkinsons Black Cow Bite Size 160pc Tub
$14.29 - $14.29
$14.29
$14.29
$14.29 - $14.29
$14.29

Atkinsons Black Cow Bite Size 160pc Tub

in stock

Atkinson’s Black Cow Bite Size candies are a classic chocolate caramel treat that comes in a 160-piece tub. These delicious candies are a little bi...

View full details
$14.29 - $14.29
$14.29
$14.29
$14.29 - $14.29
$14.29
Atkinsons Chick O Stick 24ct Box Plus Free 48ct
$31.89 - $31.89
$31.89
$31.89
$31.89 - $31.89
$31.89

Atkinsons Chick O Stick 24ct Box Plus Free 48ct

in stock

Atkinsons Chick-O-Stick is a delicious and crunchy candy that comes in a 24-count box, with a bonus of an additional 48-count for free. These candi...

View full details
$31.89 - $31.89
$31.89
$31.89
$31.89 - $31.89
$31.89
Atkinsons Crunchy Peanut Butter Bars 0.34oz 160pc Tub
$28.19 - $28.19
$28.19
$28.19
$28.19 - $28.19
$28.19

Atkinsons Crunchy Peanut Butter Bars 0.34oz 160pc Tub

in stock

Atkinsons Tubs Crunchy Peanut Butter Bars are a bulk-sized tub of 160 classic candy bars. These satisfying treats feature a rich and creamy peanut ...

View full details
$28.19 - $28.19
$28.19
$28.19
$28.19 - $28.19
$28.19
Mary Jane Molasses and Peanut Butter 160ct Jar
$16.59 - $16.59
$16.59
$16.59
$16.59 - $16.59
$16.59

Mary Jane Molasses and Peanut Butter 160ct Jar

Only 3 left!

Mary Jane is a brand of molasses and peanut butter candy made by the Atkinson Candy Company. These candies are known for their unique flavor combin...

View full details
$16.59 - $16.59
$16.59
$16.59
$16.59 - $16.59
$16.59
Mary Jane Molasses and Peanut Butter 3oz Bag
$2.69 - $2.69
$2.69
$2.69
$2.69 - $2.69
$2.69

Mary Jane Molasses and Peanut Butter 3oz Bag

in stock

Treat yourself to the classic flavor of Mary Jane Molasses and Peanut Butter in a convenient 3oz bag. Savor the sweet molasses paired with crea...

View full details
$2.69 - $2.69
$2.69
$2.69
$2.69 - $2.69
$2.69
Atkinsons Chick O Stick 48ct Box
Sold out
$10.79 - $10.79
$10.79
$10.79
$10.79 - $10.79
$10.79

Atkinsons Chick O Stick 48ct Box

Out of stock

$10.79 - $10.79
$10.79
$10.79
$10.79 - $10.79
$10.79
Sold out

Peanut Butter Candy

Peanut butter candy is one of the most popular non-fruit candy categories, known for its rich and creamy flavor made from peanuts and sugar. Peanut-based sweets have been produced in the United States since the late 19th century, with peanut butter becoming widely used in candy during the early 20th century as it gained popularity as a food product.

This category includes several candy types, such as peanut butter cups, chewy candies, filled chocolates, and peanut butter hard candies. Peanut butter candy is typically light brown or tan in color and is often paired with chocolate in many products. Here at Candy Retailer, we carry a large selection of peanut butter candy from major brands, including 5th Avenue, Atkinson, M&M’s, Marshas Homemade Buckeyes, Mary Jane, Reese’s, Taffy Delight, and many others!