Last updated 5 months ago | Originally Published: September 15, 2023

Discover 20 Different Types of Reese’s Candy Before They’re Discontinued Forever

When it comes to candy, Reese’s is a name that needs no introduction. From the iconic Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups to the long-lasting Reese’s Pieces (thanks to E.T.), this brand has been pleasing fans for decades. But here’s the thing: Reese’s isn’t just about those classic cups! 

Indeed, the brand is a creative think tank, constantly innovating and releasing new products that deserve their moment in the spotlight. At Candy Retailer, we’ve seen firsthand how these unique treats come and go, often without the fanfare they deserve. 

That’s why we’ve taken it upon ourselves to dig deep, do the research, and bring you a curated list of Reese’s currently available products, but how long will they be around, only time will tell, but we don’t they’ll be around for long! 

We want you to experience the full spectrum of Reese’s goodness, and we want you to do it before these hidden gems disappear from the shelves forever! 

The Top 20 Reese’s Must-Try List

Before we dive into this mouthwatering list, let’s set the stage. We’ve scoured the candy aisles, consulted with Reese’s enthusiasts, and even taste-tested these ourselves to bring you a list that’s not just a random assortment but a carefully crafted guide to Reese’s unique line of products. 

We’ve put in the time, the research, and, yes, the calories to ensure that what you’re about to read is the ultimate guide to lesser-known Reese’s products. We’re talking about flavors, textures, and combinations you might not have known existed. 

So, prepare to have your taste buds awakened and your candy horizons expanded. We’ve put a lot of thought into creating this list, and we hope it serves as a useful resource for discovering new Reese’s delights before they vanish into candy history! 

1. Reese’s Big Cup with Reese’s Puffs Cereal Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

Imagine the joy of biting into a Reese’s Big Cup but with an added crunch and a hint of breakfast delight. That’s what you get with this innovative product. Reese’s Puffs cereal is mixed into the peanut butter filling, offering a familiar and new texture. 

The milk chocolate shell holds it all together in a harmonious blend that’s hard to resist. While the concept might sound unconventional, the execution is spot-on, making it a must-try for anyone looking to experience Reese’s in a new way. But act fast—given its unique nature, there’s no telling how long this product will stay on the market.

2. Reese’s Take 5

If you’re the type who can’t decide between salty and sweet snacks, Reese’s Take 5 is the answer to your dilemma. This bar is a masterful blend of five key ingredients: pretzels, caramel, peanut butter, peanuts, and chocolate. 

Each component complements the others, creating a balanced flavor profile that hits all the right notes. The pretzels add a satisfying crunch, while the caramel lends a smooth, creamy contrast. The peanut butter and peanuts stay true to the Reese’s brand, and the chocolate ties them all together. 

Despite its complexity, this bar has managed to stick around, suggesting it has found a loyal following. But don’t take its longevity for granted; try it before it becomes another entry on the list of discontinued Reese’s products.

3. Reese’s Crunchy

For those who love a little extra texture in their treats, Reese’s Crunchy is a game-changer! This version takes the iconic Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup and infuses it with crunchy peanut bits, creating a contrast that elevates the entire eating experience. 

The milk chocolate exterior remains the same, serving as a rich, velvety counterpoint to the textured filling. It’s a simple twist on a classic, but sometimes, simplicity is all you need to make something extraordinary. 

If you’re a fan of crunch in your confections, don’t sleep on this one; its unique appeal might not keep it on shelves forever!

4. Reese’s Creamy

On the other end of the texture spectrum, we have Reese’s Creamy. This variant is for those who relish the silky-smooth texture of peanut butter melding with milk chocolate. 

The peanut butter in this cup is processed to an extra-smooth consistency, making each bite a luxurious experience. It’s like the classic Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup, but imagine it wearing a velvet robe. 

The milk chocolate shell is the same as you’d find in the traditional cup, but the smoother interior makes it feel like a completely different treat. 

If you’re in the mood for something that prioritizes smoothness, this is the Reese’s product to try. But don’t wait too long; its specialized nature might make it a candidate for future discontinuation.

5. Reese’s Fast Break

Reese’s Fast Break is a candy bar that has proven it’s staying power, and for good reason. This bar is a trifecta of nougat, peanut butter, and milk chocolate, each layer contributing to a harmonious blend of flavors and textures. 

The nougat provides a soft, chewy base that complements the rich, creamy layer of peanut butter. Finally, the milk chocolate coating adds Reese’s familiar touch, rounding out the experience. 

It’s a versatile treat that works well as a quick snack or a more indulgent moment. While it has managed to stick around longer than some other Reese variants, it’s always good to appreciate such gems before they possibly disappear.

6. Reese’s White Cream Peanut Butter Pumpkins

When Halloween rolls around, Reese’s White Cream Peanut Butter Pumpkins make their much-anticipated appearance. These seasonal delights swap out the traditional milk chocolate for a white cream coating, offering a different take on Reese’s experience. 

The pumpkin shape adds a festive touch, making them perfect for holiday gatherings or enjoying a crisp autumn day. The white cream brings a different flavor profile to the table, which pairs exceptionally well with the classic peanut butter filling. 

But remember, these are a seasonal offering, and there’s no guarantee they’ll return each year. So, if you spot them, it’s wise to stock up.

7. Reese’s Franken Cups

When it comes to seasonal creativity, Reese’s doesn’t hold back, and the Franken Cups are a prime example. These Halloween-themed treats feature the classic milk chocolate and peanut butter duo but with a twist: the bottom layer of the cup is made of green-colored creme. 

This adds a visual surprise and a slightly different flavor profile. The green creme is a fun nod to Frankenstein’s monster, making these cups a hit at Halloween parties or for anyone looking to get into the spooky spirit. 

But like all good things that come with the season, these Franken Cups are not long for this world. Make sure to snag a pack before they vanish into the Halloween mist.

8. Reese’s Plant-Based Oat Chocolate Confection & Peanut Butter Bars

In a move that caters to the growing demand for plant-based options, Reese’s has introduced their Plant-Based Oat Chocolate Confection & Peanut Butter Bars. 

These bars swap out the traditional milk chocolate for plant-based oat chocolate, which pairs beautifully with the classic Reese’s peanut butter. The result is a treat that’s not only delicious but also a bit more inclusive, allowing those with dietary restrictions to join in on the fun. 

Despite their appeal, these bars are not widely known and can be hard to find, making them a sort of hidden gem in the Reese’s lineup. Given their niche market, they might not stick around for long, so if you come across them, it’s worth giving them a try.

9. Reese’s Big Cup with Potato Chips

In a bold move combining two snack favorites, Reese’s Big Cup with Potato Chips is a culinary experiment sure to raise eyebrows—and perhaps delight taste buds. This variant takes the Reese’s Big Cup you know and love and adds a layer of crushed potato chips to the peanut butter filling. 

The salty crunch of the chips offers an unexpected but intriguing contrast to the sweet and creamy elements of the cup. It’s a snack that challenges conventional candy norms, making it a must-try for the adventurous eater. 

However, its unique nature could be both its strength and its downfall, as it’s unclear how long this daring combination will remain on the market.

10. Reese’s Big Cup with Pretzels & Peanut Butter

For those who enjoy the salty-sweet combo but are looking for something a bit less adventurous than potato chips, the Reese’s Big Cup with Pretzels & Peanut Butter offers a more familiar alternative. 

This version incorporates small pretzel bits into the classic Reese’s Big Cup, adding a satisfying crunch and a touch of saltiness to the mix. The pretzels work harmoniously with the peanut butter and chocolate, creating a balanced flavor profile that’s both comforting and exciting. 

Given its more traditional appeal, this variant may have a better chance of becoming a mainstay in Reese’s lineup. But as with all limited-edition treats, it’s best to try it sooner rather than later.

11. Reese’s Chocolate Lovers

For those who can’t get enough of the chocolate component in Reese’s, the Chocolate Lovers made with Milk Chocolate is a dream come true. This variant amplifies the chocolate factor, featuring a thicker milk chocolate shell that encases the peanut butter filling. 

The result is a more chocolate-forward experience, where the rich and creamy milk chocolate takes center stage without overshadowing the peanut butter. It’s a harmonious balance that caters specifically to those who lean toward the cocoa side of things. 

Given its appeal to chocolate fans, this variant has a good chance of becoming a permanent fixture in the Reese family.

12. Reese’s Eggs

When Easter rolls around, Reese’s Eggs become a staple in candy aisles and Easter baskets alike. These egg-shaped treats offer the same delightful combination of milk chocolate and peanut butter, but their seasonal shape provides a slightly different ratio that some fans swear by. 

The flatter, more spread-out form allows for a more even distribution of chocolate and peanut butter in each bite. Considering their consistent popularity year after year, Reese’s Eggs will likely remain a seasonal favorite, making them one of the more secure options for those looking to indulge without the fear of future discontinuation.

13. Reese’s Mallow-Top Marshmallow Creme with Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

If you’ve ever wondered what a Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup would taste like with a layer of marshmallow, wonder no more. The Reese’s Mallow-Top features a layer of marshmallow creme atop the classic peanut butter filling; all encased in milk chocolate. 

This addition brings a light, airy quality to the treat, contrasting the denser, richer peanut butter and chocolate layers. The marshmallow creme adds a subtle sweetness that complements rather than overwhelms the other flavors. 

Despite its appeal, this variant hasn’t gained as much attention as some others, making its future uncertain. If you’re intrigued by the idea of a marshmallow-infused Reese’s, try it now while it’s still available!

14. Reese’s Big Cup Peanut Brittle

When the holiday season arrives, Reese’s Big Cup Peanut Brittle makes its festive debut. This Christmas special takes the Reese’s Big Cup and infuses it with peanut brittle-flavored creme and crunchy peanut butter. 

The result is a treat that captures the essence of the holiday season, offering a unique blend of flavors that evoke the traditional peanut brittle many enjoy during the holidays. The peanut brittle-flavored creme adds a nutty, caramelized note that pairs perfectly with the crunchy peanut butter and milk chocolate. 

While it’s a hit during Christmas, its seasonal nature means it’s unavailable year-round. So, if you’re a peanut brittle and Reese’s fan, this is a must-try during the holiday season.

15. Reese’s Dark Chocolate Dipped Pretzels

If you’re a fan of the darker, more intense cocoa flavors, Reese’s Dark Chocolate Dipped Pretzels are a treat you won’t want to miss. These pretzels are dipped in a rich dark chocolate that’s infused with the signature Reese’s peanut butter flavor. 

The result is a snack that balances the salty crunch of pretzels with dark chocolate’s deep, complex notes. Its combination works incredibly well, offering a more mature take on the classic Reese’s flavor profile. 

However, this product hasn’t received much attention despite its merits, putting its longevity in question. If you’re intrigued by the idea of a dark chocolate Reese’s experience, it’s worth seeking these out before they potentially disappear.

16. Reese’s Sticks

For those who enjoy the crispy texture of wafers, Reese’s Sticks offer a delightful alternative to the traditional Reese’s cup. These treats feature layers of crispy wafers and peanut butter, all coated in milk chocolate. 

The wafers add a light, airy crunch that contrasts nicely with the creamy peanut butter and smooth chocolate. It’s a different kind of Reese’s experience that leans into texture as much as it does flavor. 

While they offer a unique and enjoyable eating experience, their divergence from the classic Reese’s formula might make them less likely to stick around for the long term. If you’re a fan of wafer-based treats, these are worth trying while they’re still on the market.

17. Reese’s XL Peanut Butter Candy Bar

For those who believe that bigger is indeed better, Reese’s XL Peanut Butter Candy Bar offers a supersized Reese’s experience. This bar takes the classic combination of milk chocolate and peanut butter and scales it up, delivering more of the flavors you love in a single package. 

It’s essentially a stretched-out version of the iconic Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup, offering more surface area for that delicious peanut butter filling. Despite its generous size and the promise of more Reese’s goodness, this variant has not been as prominently featured as others, making its future somewhat uncertain. 

If you’ve ever found yourself wanting just a bit more from your Reese’s, this is the one to try—while it’s still around.

18. Reese’s Outrageous!

Reese’s Outrageous! Bar is aptly named, offering a flavor experience that goes above and beyond the standard Reese’s fare. This bar features peanut butter and caramel layers, all studded with Reese’s Pieces and coated in milk chocolate. 

The inclusion of Reese’s Pieces adds a delightful crunch, while the caramel layer brings a gooey sweetness that complements the peanut butter and chocolate perfectly. It’s a complex, multi-layered treat that has captured Reese’s fans’ attention, becoming a top seller at Candy Retailer. 

Taking its popularity and unique flavor profile, this bar seems to have secured its place in the Reese’s lineup—for now, at least.

19. Reese’s Snack Bar

The Reese’s Snack Bar offers an interesting alternative for those looking for a Reese’s experience that leans a bit more toward the wholesome side. 

This bar features whole-grain brown rice, peanuts, and peanut butter creme, making it a more textured and slightly less indulgent option. Despite its unique ingredients, it still captures the essence of Reese’s with its peanut butter and chocolate flavors. 

However, its lesser-known status and unconventional ingredient list make it a wild card in terms of longevity. If you’re curious about Reese’s product that offers a different texture and a slightly more nutritious profile, this is one to try before it fades into obscurity.

20. Reese’s Snack Cake

If you’ve ever wished for a Reese’s product that could legitimately pass as breakfast, the Reese’s Snack Cake might be your dream come true. This treat features a soft-baked chocolate cake that’s topped with Reese’s peanut butter creme and coated in milk chocolate. 

It’s like a portable, snack-sized version of a chocolate peanut butter cake. The cake base adds a new textural element, making it softer and more tender than your typical Reese’s product. The peanut butter creme and milk chocolate ensure that it’s unmistakably Reese’s. 

Understanding its unique format and delicious flavor, we hope this one sticks around for the long haul. But as with any unique product, there’s always the risk of discontinuation, so it might be wise to try it sooner rather than later!

Discontinued Reese’s Candy Gone But Not Forgotten

While we’ve spent a lot of time highlighting Reese’s products you should try before they potentially disappear, it’s worth taking a moment to remember those that have already left us. 

The world of candy is ever-changing, and even a brand as iconic as Reese’s isn’t immune to the cycle of introduction and discontinuation. The following list serves as a sort of “in memoriam” for Reese’s products that were once on the shelves but are no longer available. 

Each had its unique twist on the classic Reese’s formula, and each had its own fans who mourned its loss. Whether it was a seasonal special or a daring flavor experiment, these discontinued items are a testament to Reese’s spirit of innovation—even when that innovation doesn’t stand the test of time.

• Reese’s Caramel
• Big Cup with Mixed Nuts
• Reese’s Peanut Butter & Banana Creme
• Reese’s Honey Roasted Peanut Butter Cups
• Reese’s Snacksters
• Reese’s Swoops
• Reese’s Inside Out
• Reese’s Whipps
• Reese’s Pieces With Nuts
• Reese’s White Creme Peanut Butter Cups stuffed with Reese’s Pieces

We’re sure we’ve missed some, so if you remember a discontinued Reese’s product that’s not on this list, feel free to jog our memory. 

It’s a bittersweet walk down memory lane, but it also serves as a reminder to enjoy the current offerings while they’re still here. After all, you never know which of today’s Reese’s products might end up on a future list like this one!