Last updated 5 months ago | Originally Published: September 28, 2023

Discover the Best Trick or Treat Candy that Money Can Buy

Are you gearing up for the spookiest night of the year and wondering what trick-or-treat candy will make your local visitors smile the most? If so, look no further than here at Candy Retailer! 

We offer a wide range of sweets here in our candy store and bring you the most reliable and accurate information about candies through our daily blog posts! 

Today, we’re excited to present the ultimate list of trick-or-treat candies that are sure to be a hit this Halloween. 

Based on real in-house data and expert reviews, this list is the only guide you’ll need to make this year’s Halloween a sweet success! So, let’s dive right in and discover the candies that’ll make your house the talk of the town!

The True History of Trick or Treat Candy

Before diving into our list of best trick-or-treat candies, we first wanted to share a little story with you about the history of this beloved annual ritual. 

Indeed, the tradition of trick-or-treating has a rich and varied history that goes beyond just knocking on doors and collecting candy and sweets. 

Although the exact origins of the phrase “trick or treat” aren’t entirely clear, the custom had been firmly established in American popular culture by 1951. 

The practice became widespread in the U.S. after World War II, driven by the country’s suburbanization, allowing kids to travel door to door seeking candy from their neighbors safely.

Interestingly, the roots of trick-or-treating can be traced back to Celtic pagan traditions. The holiday of Samhain celebrated around October 31 in what is now Ireland, is considered a precursor to modern Halloween. 

Over time, the tradition evolved and was influenced by various cultures and practices, eventually becoming the candy-filled event we know today.

At Candy Retailer, we appreciate the historical significance of this tradition, which has evolved to become a beloved annual event for families across America. It’s not just about the candy; it’s about community, celebration, and a little bit of magic that makes Halloween special. 

As America’s favorite online candy store, we’re thrilled to be a part of this enduring tradition! Now, let’s get to the sweet part—our ultimate list of trick-or-treat candies that you’ll want to know about before October 31st. 

Our Top List of Best Trick-or-Treat Candy Begins Now

Before we dive into Candy Retailer’s handpicked list of Halloween treats, let’s set the stage. All the candies on this list are individually wrapped, making them perfect for trick-or-treaters. But we’ve got something special for the candy giver also—stay tuned for that sweet surprise at the end of our list! 

Charms Blow Pop Creepy Treats 80ct Bag

This 80-count bag of Charms Blow Pop Creepy Treats offers a two-in-one candy experience. First, enjoy the fruity outer layer and discover the bubblegum center. With an average price of $12.39, it’s a budget-friendly option for Halloween festivities. Don’t miss out on this dual delight—add Charms Blow Pop Creepy Treats to your cart today!

Dubble Bubble Ghoul’s Gum 175ct Bag

Packed with 175 pieces, the Dubble Bubble Ghoul’s Gum is a Halloween essential. The gum offers a burst of classic flavor that kids and adults alike will enjoy. Priced at an average of $13.19, it’s an affordable way to keep the Halloween spirit alive. Make your Halloween pop with Dubble Bubble Ghoul’s Gum—order now!

Dubble Bubble Halloween Combo Gumball Bag 12oz Bag

This 12-ounce bag is a Halloween special, featuring a variety of gumball flavors and colors to suit the festive season. It’s a fun and flavorful addition to your Halloween candy lineup. Priced at an average of $4.49, it’s a steal. Grab yours today to add a burst of flavor to your Halloween celebrations!

Dubble Bubble Pumpkin Gumballs 9.86oz Bag

With 9.86 ounces, or 50 pieces, of pumpkin-shaped gumballs, this bag brings a unique twist to your Halloween treats. The gumballs are eye-catching and offer the classic Dubble Bubble taste. Available at an average price of $4.49, it’s an affordable way to add some seasonal flair to your candy selection. Order yours now for a ghoulishly good time!

Jelly Belly BeanBoozled 3.5oz Spinner Gift Box

Add a touch of excitement to your Halloween festivities with this 3.5-ounce spinner gift box from Jelly Belly. It offers a unique and interactive candy experience. Priced at an average of $7.89, consider passing it out to your favorite customer of the night. Make someone’s Halloween extra special—pick one up today!

Wack-O-Wax Assorted Wax Fangs 24ct Box

Ample opportunities for fun Halloween photos and memories come with each 24-count pack of assorted wax fangs. Going beyond taste, they offer a playful and interactive candy experience. With an average price of $36.29, elevate your Halloween celebrations with this premium choice. Secure yours now, and let the Halloween hijinks begin!

Wack-O-Wax Assorted Wax Lips 24ct Box

Elevate your Halloween experience with these whimsical wax lips that double as a fun accessory. A 24-count pack ensures there’s enough fun for everyone. At an average price of $36.29, they’re perfect for adding a playful touch to your celebrations. Get your pack today for a memorable Halloween!

Alberts Halloween Giant Candy Mix 3lb Bag

Be the hero of Halloween in your neighborhood by stocking up on this 3-pound bag of Alberts Halloween Giant Candy Mix. It offers a diverse selection of candies to satisfy a variety of tastes. An average price of $9.09 makes it an economical choice for a one-stop Halloween shop.

Fun Dip Halloween 44ct Box

Interactive fun comes in a 44-count box of Fun Dip, a nostalgic favorite. It offers a unique eating experience that’s perfect for Halloween. Priced at an average of $9.39, it’s a budget-friendly way to add excitement to your celebrations. Don’t miss out—grab your box today!

Palmer Googly Eyes Halloween Candy 1lb

For a visually delightful Halloween, consider this 1-pound bag of Palmer Googly Eyes. Its eye-catching design is a hit with trick-or-treaters and offers a creative twist on traditional Halloween candy. At an average price of $5.39, it’s an affordable way to stand out this Halloween. Secure a bag now!

Palmer Tricky Treat Halloween Candy 1lb

Bring smiles to little faces this Halloween with a 1-pound bag, or 240 pieces, of Palmer Tricky Treat. It offers a variety of Halloween-themed candies that are sure to delight. Priced at an average of $4.39, it’s a cost-effective addition to your Halloween shopping list. Act fast and add it to your cart!

Goetzes Cow Tales Caramel Minis 4lb

Indulge in quality with a 4-pound bag of Goetzes Cow Tales Caramel Minis. These individually wrapped minis are perfect for sharing and offer a premium caramel experience. With an average price of $51.89, it’s a luxurious treat for those who appreciate the finer things. Order your bag today for a blissful caramel experience!

Jolly Rancher Assorted 1lb

Bursting with fruity flavors, a 1-pound bag of Jolly Rancher Assorted candies is a hit with both kids and adults. At an affordable average price of $5.79, it’s a colorful addition to your Halloween candy lineup. Add a splash of fruitiness to your Halloween—grab a bag today!

Laffy Taffy Mini Assorted Bulk 1lb

Priced at an average of $6.29, this bulk bag of mini Laffy Taffy offers a chewy, fruity experience that’s perfect for Halloween. The assortment ensures a variety of flavors to please everyone. Elevate your Halloween candy game—order a bag today!

Now and Later Original Mix Mini Bars Tub

For those who enjoy a long-lasting chew, the Now and Later Original Mix Mini Bars are an excellent choice. The tub format makes it convenient for sharing and serving. With an average price of $19.49, it’s a premium option for a classic candy. Add a touch of nostalgia to your Halloween—get your tub now!

Smarties Original Candy Rolls 180ct Tub

At an average price of $21.69, this 180-count tub of Smarties Original Candy Rolls offers a sugar rush in a small, disc-shaped form. The tub makes it easy to share these nostalgic favorites. Sweeten up your Halloween festivities—grab a tub today!

Airheads Assorted 60ct Box

Priced at an average of $14.89, the 60-count box of Airheads Assorted provides a chewy, fruit-flavored treat that’s sure to be a hit. The assortment includes multiple flavors, making it a versatile choice for Halloween. Add some chewy excitement to your Halloween—pick up a box now!

Skittles and Starburst 30ct Variety Pack

With an average price of $36.69, this variety pack combines the fruity flavors of Skittles and the juicy goodness of Starburst. It’s a versatile choice that offers something for everyone this Halloween. Add a burst of fruitiness to your Halloween treats—secure your value box today!

Hershey’s Assorted Miniatures 120ct Box

Available at an average price of $15.99, this 120-count box of Hershey’s Assorted Miniatures brings together classic chocolate favorites. It’s a reliable and beloved choice for Halloween candy. Make your Halloween a chocolatey affair—order your box now!

Hershey’s Kit Kat and Reeses Bulk Variety 30ct Box

Combining the crunch of Kit Kat with the creamy peanut butter of Reese’s, this 30-count variety box is a chocolate lover’s dream. With an average price of $39.49, it’s a premium selection for a high-quality Halloween. Indulge in the best of both worlds—get your box today!

M & M Variety Pack 30ct Box

Featuring an assortment of M&M’s flavors, this 30-count variety pack is a colorful and tasty addition to your Halloween candy lineup. Priced at an average of $36.69, it offers a range of options for chocolate enthusiasts. Brighten up your Halloween with colorful chocolate—secure your pack now!

Peanut Butter Pumpkin Cups 1lb

Priced at an average of $6.19, this 1-pound bag of Peanut Butter Pumpkin Cups offers a seasonal twist on a classic flavor combination. It’s a delightful way to celebrate the Halloween season. Satisfy your peanut butter cravings—add a bag to your cart now!

Reese’s White Pumpkins 36ct Box

With an average price of $34.39, this 36-count box of Reese’s White Pumpkins brings a unique, creamy variation to the traditional Reese’s experience. It’s a luxurious choice for those looking to add a special touch to their Halloween candy offerings. Experience the creamy side of Halloween—order your box today!

Brach’s Candy Corn and Autumn Mix for Candy Givers

Brach’s Autumn Mix is a delightful seasonal offering that combines the best of Halloween and fall in one package. This mix includes Pumpkin Mallowcreams, Harvest Corn, and Classic Candy Corn, making it a versatile addition to any candy bowl. 

The candy is made from high-quality ingredients, including a touch of honey, which sets it apart from other candy corn products, usually sugar and corn syrup.

Brach’s encourages creativity with their Autumn Mix. You can use these candies to decorate baked goods or snack on them. 

The mix is a sweet treat for anyone, adding a colorful flair to your Halloween and fall celebrations. So, whether you’re looking to enhance your baked creations or fill your candy bowl with something that screams “autumn,” Brach’s Autumn Mix is the go-to choice!

Wrapping Up Your Trick-or-Treat Candy Selection for a Safe and Memorable Halloween

As we conclude, it’s clear that choosing the right Trick-or-Treat Candy can make all the difference in creating a memorable Halloween experience. 

From the history of Trick-or-Treat Candy to our carefully curated list of top picks, we’ve aimed to provide you with a comprehensive guide to make your Halloween as sweet as possible. 

Whether you’re the one trick-or-treating or the generous soul handing out candy, we hope this guide helps you make the best choices for a spooktacular Halloween. Thank you for choosing Candy Retailer as your go-to source for all things candy. Happy Halloween!