Last updated 4 months ago | Originally Published: May 22, 2024

Discover the Top 20 Peanut Butter Candies of All Time

If you love peanut butter candies and candy bars, then you’re really going to appreciate the list we put together for you today! Not only have these candies stood the test of time, but they’re also loved by millions and will likely top the candy charts forever! 

In this post, we’ll list the best of the best, tell you about the history of this candy flavor, share some fun facts, and tell you about each brand/ product, including how you can buy it here at Candy Retailer in bulk for cheap! Our content is based on facts and intended to inform, educate, and save money on all your favorite peanut butter candies! 

Top 20 Best Peanut Butter Candies Ever Made

To begin with, we’ll start with our list of the best peanut butter candies still in production today! Please comment below and add your favorite to the list if we missed anything. Not only will we recognize you for your contribution, but you’ll also be helping others find long-lost favorites or perhaps something new! 

1. 5th Avenue

The 5th Avenue bar, introduced by Hershey’s in 1936, features a crunchy peanut butter center coated in rich milk chocolate. The Luden company originally created it and was later acquired by Hershey’s in 1986. The candy bar is known for its unique texture, combining a crisp, peanut butter-flavored toffee with a smooth chocolate exterior, making it a long-standing favorite among those who appreciate peanut butter candy!

2. Anthony Thomas Buckeyes

Anthony Thomas Buckeyes are a traditional confection named after the nut of the Ohio buckeye tree. These candies consist of a creamy peanut butter center partially dipped in rich chocolate, resembling the appearance of a buckeye nut. Made by Anthony Thomas, a renowned chocolatier based in Ohio, these candies are trendy during the holiday season and are often associated with Midwestern U.S. culture.

3. Atkinson’s Chick-O-Stick

Atkinson’s Chick-O-Stick is a nostalgic candy featuring a crunchy, honeycombed peanut butter and toasted coconut center. This candy product was created in the 1930s and is known for its distinctive orange color and unique texture. Produced by the Atkinson Candy Company in Texas, Chick-O-Stick is available in stick and bite-sized pieces, making it a versatile and enduring choice for peanut butter candy lovers.

4. Atkinson’s Peanut Butter Bars

Atkinson’s Peanut Butter Bars are a classic candy made by the Atkinson Candy Company. These bars feature a crunchy, peanut butter-flavored toffee center, offering a satisfying combination of sweetness and texture. Known for their simple ingredients and distinctive taste, Peanut Butter Bars have been popular since their introduction. These bars are individually wrapped, making them convenient for snacking and sharing.

5. Boyer Peanut Butter Cups

Boyer Peanut Butter Cups, created by the Boyer Candy Company, offer a twist on the traditional peanut butter cup. Each cup features a smooth peanut butter filling encased in a layer of rich milk chocolate. Introduced in the mid-20th century, Boyer Peanut Butter Cups are known for their generous peanut butter portion and distinct flavor. These candies are made in Altoona, Pennsylvania, and are a favorite among peanut butter candy fans.

6. Butterfinger

Butterfinger is a well-known candy bar introduced by the Curtiss Candy Company in 1923 and is now produced by Ferrero. It features a flaky, crisp peanut butter center covered in a layer of milk chocolate. The unique texture and distinctive taste of Butterfinger have made it a popular choice for nearly a century. The candy bar has undergone various recipe updates over the years but remains a beloved candy bar worldwide.

7. Clark Peanut Butter Cups

Clark Peanut Butter Cups are a product of the iconic Clark Bar brand, known for its unique combination of flavors. These cups feature a smooth, creamy peanut butter filling encased in a rich milk chocolate shell and originating from the original Clark Bar, which was first introduced in 1917 by the D.L. Clark Company; these peanut butter cups carry on the tradition of high-quality, delicious confections. The Boyer Candy Company in Altoona, Pennsylvania, now produces them.

8. M&M’s Peanut Butter

M&M’s Peanut Butter, introduced by Mars, Inc. in 1990, is a popular variation of the classic M&M’s candy. Each piece consists of a peanut butter core surrounded by milk chocolate and encased in a colorful candy shell. The smooth peanut butter, rich chocolate, and iconic crunchy coating make these M&M’s a favorite among candy fans. They are available in various packaging options and are suitable for sharing or individual enjoyment.

9. Mary Jane Molasses and Peanut Butter

Mary Jane Molasses and Peanut Butter candies are nostalgic candies initially created by the Charles N. Miller Company in 1914 and later produced by Necco. These chewy candies have a distinctive molasses flavor and a rich peanut butter center. Named after the creator’s favorite aunt, Mary Jane, they are recognized for their unique taste and classic yellow and red wrappers. They have been a staple in the American candy landscape for over a century.

10. Palmer Peanut Butter Hearts

Palmer Peanut Butter Hearts, produced by R.M. Palmer Company, is a seasonal candy often associated with Valentine’s Day. Each heart-shaped confection features a creamy peanut butter filling encased in a smooth milk chocolate shell. Known for their festive packaging and rich taste, these candies offer a delightful combination of flavors and textures, making them a popular gift and snack during the holiday season.

11. Peanut Butter Kisses

Peanut Butter Kisses are a traditional Halloween candy known for their distinctive orange and black wax wrappers. These chewy candies feature a peanut butter-flavored center mixed with a taffy-like consistency. Often made by various confectioners, they have been a nostalgic favorite for many generations. Combining the sweet taffy and rich peanut butter creates a unique taste experience that remains popular during Halloween.

12. Reese’s Nutrageous

Reese’s Nutrageous, introduced by The Hershey Company in 1994, is a candy bar that combines several layers of indulgent flavors. It features a peanut butter core surrounded by caramel, studded with crunchy peanuts, and coated in milk chocolate. This multi-textured candy offers a rich, satisfying taste experience, making it a popular choice among peanut butter and chocolate lovers. Reese’s Nutrageous remains a standout product in Reese’s lineup.

13. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, created by The Hershey Company in 1928, are a staple in the candy world. Each cup contains a smooth peanut butter filling encased in a rich milk chocolate shell. Known for their perfect balance of sweet and salty flavors, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups are available in various sizes and packaging options. They remain one of the most popular and recognizable peanut butter candies globally.

14. Reese’s Take 5

Reese’s Take 5 is a candy bar introduced by The Hershey Company in 2004. It combines five distinct layers: pretzels, caramel, peanut butter, peanuts, and milk chocolate. The unique blend of sweet, salty, and crunchy textures makes Reese’s Take 5 a standout product from this brand. Known for its innovative flavor combination, this candy bar offers a satisfying snack experience and is a favorite among consumers.

15. Reese’s Pieces

Reese’s Pieces, launched by The Hershey Company in 1978, are small, bite-sized candies with a smooth peanut butter center encased in a crunchy candy shell. Available in orange, yellow, and brown colors, they became widely popular after being featured in the 1982 film “E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial.” Known for their convenient size and distinct flavor, Reese’s Pieces are a popular snack and a staple in the Reese’s product lineup.

16. Reppert’s Fall Peanut Butter Nonpareils

Reppert’s Fall Peanut Butter Nonpareils are a seasonal candy produced by Reppert’s Candy Company. These candies feature a rich peanut butter center covered in a layer of chocolate and sprinkled with festive fall-colored nonpareil sprinkles. Known for their high-quality ingredients and delightful taste, Reppert’s Nonpareils are a popular choice during autumn, offering a unique twist on traditional nonpareil confections.

17. Snickers Peanut Butter

Snickers Peanut Butter, introduced by Mars, Inc., is a variation of the classic Snickers bar. It features layers of peanut butter, nougat, caramel, and peanuts, all covered in milk chocolate. This combination provides a rich, creamy, and crunchy texture, blending the iconic Snickers flavors with smooth peanut butter. Snickers Peanut Butter offers a satisfying option for peanut butter candy fans; however, it’s not always an easy find. 

18. Taffy Town Peanut Butter Salt Water Taffy

Taffy Town Peanut Butter Salt Water Taffy is a soft, chewy candy produced by Taffy Town, a family-owned company since 1916. This taffy features a distinct peanut butter flavor, achieved through a whipping process that ensures a light, airy texture. Known for its smooth consistency and rich taste, Taffy Town’s Peanut Butter Salt Water Taffy is a popular choice among taffy lovers and is available in various packaging options for convenience.

19. Whozeewhatzit

Whozeewhatzit is a candy bar introduced by The Hershey Company in 2021 as an extension of the Whatchamacallit brand. This bar features a creamy peanut butter layer on top of a crispy rice and cocoa core, all coated in a rich layer of chocolate. The unique combination of textures and flavors offers a satisfying crunch and a smooth peanut butter taste, making it a modern addition to popular peanut butter candies.

20. Zagnut

Zagnut, created by the D.L. Clark Company in 1930 and now produced by The Hershey Company, is a unique candy bar known for its crunchy peanut butter and toasted coconut center. Unlike many other peanut butter candies, Zagnut does not contain chocolate. The combination of flavors and textures provides a distinct taste experience. The bar’s bright red packaging and enduring recipe have kept it a nostalgic favorite for many candy lovers.

The Best Selling Peanut Butter Candy Brand of All Time

Reese’s is the best-selling peanut butter candy brand of all time! As of late 2023, it had achieved over $3 Billion in annual sales, securing its position as the top-selling candy brand in the United States and globally. Owned by The Hershey Company, Reese’s is the most recognizable brand known for its iconic peanut butter and chocolate combination.

With a history stretching back nearly a decade, Reese’s continues to innovate and expand its product line. Beyond the classic Peanut Butter Cups, the brand includes Reese’s Pieces, Reese’s Take 5, and more. The beloved brand has also ventured into various other products, incorporating its signature flavors into pretzels, potato chips, Reese’s Puffs Cereal, animal crackers, and popcorn, all of which you can find here at Candy Retailer! 

Join the Conversation

We hope you enjoyed our list of the best peanut butter candies still made today! If we missed any of your favorites, please list them in the comments below so others can discover or rediscover a forgotten favorite! We’d love to hear from you!

Don’t forget to connect with us on social media for newly published stories, sales, and important announcements such as new product releases and recalls. Alternatively, if you’d like to skip all that and dive right into the candy jar, check out all our peanut butter candies available here at Candy Retailer by clicking on the link provided.