Last updated 4 months ago | Originally Published: September 30, 2023

Your #1 Guide to the Best Peanut Butter Candy Begins Now

If you love peanut butter candy, then you’re really going to enjoy this we put together for you today! As many of you know, we’re one of the nation’s most visited candy stores in the country!

Plus, we’re building out the most diverse snack and candy blogs ever published online. Currently, we offer over 20,000 different types of sweet and salty products, so our goal is to tell you everything about our items!

That’s right; here at the Candy Retailer Blog, you can find everything from snack and candy news, history, lists, and other informational posts about your favorite brands and flavors! 

Manifesting our goals, we’re now building out our Candy by Flavor category, which has led us straight to peanut butter candy! We have over 100 different types, and we’ll reveal some of our best-sellers in the list published below! 

On that note, we’d love to share every type of peanut butter candy we have, but then that might take away from all the fun once you discover our category page! 

The Ultimate Peanut Butter Candy List

Before we proceed with our mega list of best-selling peanut butter candy in America, we first want to let you know that Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups and Butterfinger candy bars will not be included in our list today. 

Indeed, the two are powerhouse peanut butter candies, and we already know they’re the best, but we wanted this list to include PB Candy, which often gets shadowed by Reese’s and Butterfinger. So, without further ado, let’s discover more! 

1. Atkinson Peanut Butter Candy 

Atkinson’s range of peanut butter candies is nothing short of impressive. We’ve got everything from Peanut Butter Bars to Chick-O-Sticks, Nuggets, and even Honeycombed Peanuts. Choose from a variety of packaging options to suit your needs: grab a personal 3.75oz bag for a quick treat, or go big with our 160-piece tubs, 1lb resealable bags, and boxes in counts of 24, 36, or 48. Click on the image to see the full lineup, or keep scrolling to find more peanut butter gems at Candy Retailer. 

2. Mary Jane Molasses and Peanut Butter

Step back in time with Mary Jane’s Molasses and Peanut Butter candies—a classic that has stood the test of time. Available at Candy Retailer in two convenient sizes: a generous 160-count jar for true fans or a more modest 3oz bag for those looking to sample. Click the image or button below to explore further, or continue scrolling to uncover more peanut butter delights.

3. Taffy Town Peanut Butter Flavored Salt Water Taffy

Taffy Town sets the bar high with its exceptional saltwater taffy, and its peanut butter flavor is no exception. Get your hands on this chewy goodness by the pound, and expect it at your doorstep in just 2-3 days. Click the image below to place your order, and prepare to be amazed. 

4. Zagnut Candy Bars

Craving a unique blend of crunchy peanut butter and toasted coconut? Look no further than Zagnut Candy Bars. Available at Candy Retailer in an exclusive 18-count box, these bars are a must-try for any peanut butter enthusiast. Click the image to grab your box today, or keep scrolling for more exciting options.

5. Boyer Peanut Butter Cups

Boyer Peanut Butter Cups might not be household names, but they’re stars in their own right. If you’re a fan of peanut butter candy, these cups will not disappoint. For an extra twist, try the King-Size Boyer Butterscotch Smoothie Peanut Butter Cups. Available now at Candy Retailer in a 24-count box. Click to order, or continue scrolling for more hidden gems. 

6. Boyer Clark Bar

The Clark Bar by Boyer is a classic that’s been around for ages but still flies under the radar. It’s time to give this peanut butter legend the spotlight it deserves. Order your 24-count box in regular or king-size at Candy Retailer. Click the image to make your purchase, or keep scrolling to find more peanut butter treats to love.

7. Peanut Butter M&Ms

While classic chocolate M&Ms are a go-to for many, the peanut butter variant is a hidden gem that deserves its own spotlight. There’s no need to hunt them down at various stores; we’ve got you covered with a 24-pack box right here at Candy Retailer. Click to order now, or keep scrolling to uncover more peanut butter candy options. 

8. Palmer Peanut Butter Candy

Palmer Candy has a reputation for offering budget-friendly, quality treats, and their peanut butter candies are no exception. Choose from a range of options like Peanut Butter-filled Chocolate Kringles, Peanut Butter Hearts, and even White Chocolate-flavored Peanut Butter Hearts, all available in 1lb resealable bags. Add to your cart today, or continue scrolling for more selections.

9. Peanut Butter Kisses 

A seasonal favorite, especially during Halloween, Peanut Butter Kisses are a taffy treat that can be enjoyed all year round at Candy Retailer. Available by the pound, these iconic orange and black wax-wrapped candies are just a click away. Order now for fast, nationwide delivery—right on time for any celebration. 

10. Reppert’s Fall Peanut Butter Nonpareils

Celebrate the autumn season with Repperts Fall Peanut Butter Nonpareils, adorned with festive, autumn-colored sprinkles. Available by the pound, these treats are the epitome of fall sweetness. Click to order now, or continue scrolling for more enticing options. 

11. Ashers Peanut Butter Candy

Asher’s brings a rich history of candy-making to the table, and their peanut butter offerings are no exception. Choose from seasonal favorites like Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Christmas and Easter Pals, available by the pound. Click to add these to your cart, or keep scrolling for more. 

12. Candy Retailer Peanut Butter Filled Mini Pretzel Nuggets

Yes, you read that right! We at Candy Retailer have our own line of peanut butter candies. You’re missing out if you haven’t tried our Peanut Butter Filled Mini Pretzel Nuggets. These savory-sweet bites come in a convenient 1lb resealable jar. Click to order your jar today, or keep scrolling to explore more of our peanut butter candy selection.

13. Chex Mix Peanut Butter Chocolate Bar

While not a conventional peanut butter candy, Chex Mix Peanut Butter Chocolate Bars are too good to pass up. These bars offer a unique twist on the classic flavors you love. Available at Candy Retailer in a value-size 12-count box. Click to order, or keep scrolling for more options.

14. Kellogg’s Special Chocolate Peanut Butter Bars

Another non-traditional entry, Kellogg’s Special Chocolate Peanut Butter Bars, are versatile treats that fit into any part of your day. Grab an 8-pack box today and satisfy your cravings whenever they hit. Click to make your purchase, or continue scrolling for more. 

15. Flipz Peanut Butter Filled Pretzels

Flipz Peanut Butter Filled Pretzels offer a delightful blend of savory and sweet, making them a unique addition to our list. If you’re a fan of peanut butter, these pretzels are a must-try. Click to add them to your cart, or keep scrolling to explore more. 

Reese’s Peanut Butter Candy

As we mentioned before the list, Reese’s is the leader when it comes to peanut butter candy! In fact, if we had included all the products from this iconic brand, then our list would’ve been two times longer and loaded with tons of Reese’s candy!

With this in mind, we recently published a blog post on The 20 Reese’s Peanut Butter Candy, which you can read by clicking the link we just provided or the image and button below. Here, you’ll discover all the current Reese’s products available here at Candy Retailer! 

Our Final Thoughts About Peanut Butter Candy

The love affair between Americans and peanut butter has grown exponentially over the years, finding its way into an astonishing range of foods—from smoothies to gourmet dishes. 

Yet, when it comes to candy, our confectioners were visionaries, incorporating this creamy, nutty goodness into sweets long before it became a culinary trend.

While the cost of peanut butter has surged by over 70% in the past decade, the craving for peanut butter candy remains insatiable. 

If you’re on the hunt for the most competitive prices, look no further than Candy Retailer. Our extensive selection ensures that we have something for every peanut butter lover out there, from classic bars to innovative pretzel nuggets.

We invite you to join the conversation and share your personal peanut butter candy favorites. While we’ve done our best to compile a comprehensive list, we know there are more hidden gems we’ve yet to discover, and we’re counting on you to fill in the gaps. 

Thanks for reading, and here’s to many more sweet moments ahead!