Discover the Best Caramel Candy for Any Occasion

Last updated 2 days ago | Originally Published: April 12, 2025

Discovering the best caramel candy used to be a hunt, but now it’s easier than ever, especially here at Candy Retailer! With over 140 options, and growing, to select from, you’ll be sure to find long-lost favorites, familiar brands, and new caramel candies you didn’t know existed. Our list below features hard caramel candies, caramel taffy, caramel candy bars, and caramel squares for baking! 

In addition to brands and products, caramel candy is also brown, which makes it great for color-themed parties, events, and candy buffets. However, our goal for creating this list is focused on discovery! As one of the best candy flavors ever made, there are many types, textures, and mixes, which aim to better organize so you can spend less time searching and more time doing what you do best. 

So, if you love caramel candy, check out our sneak peek below into one of our biggest, forever-expanding candy categories here at Candy Retailer. To skip our list and dive straight in, click here to view all. Either way, our list below features some of our most sought-after and purchased caramel candies we currently sell online and in our candy store located here in historic downtown Newport, KY, just south of Cincinnati. So, if you’re ever in the area, stop by and say hi, we love new smiling faces! 

Atkinson’s Slo Poke Caramel Candy

Debuting in 1926, Atkinson’s Slo Poke is one of the original caramel candy brands made and sold in the USA. If you know, you know! For those you don’t know, here’s your shot to try some of the best caramel candy, according to millions of people, throughout time! Known for its smooth, rich, chewy caramel flavor, Slo Poke is sold here at Candy Retailer by the pound, making it a perfect bulk candy option for those looking to spend less for their favorite, American-made caramel candy brand. View all Atkinon’s caramel candies here. 

Brach’s Classic Hard Caramels

Formally known as Nips Candy, Brach’s Classic Hard Candies are just as smooth, creamy, and superior tasting as they always were, only the name has changed, not the flavor or quality! Now made by Ferrara Candy Company, Brach’s is now our 2nd best-selling caramel hard candy brand after Werther’s Original, which is also on this list. You can also get these caramel candies here at Candy Retailer in single 3.25oz bags or a bulk-size 12-pack case. If this is the one for you, click below and bring ‘em home! Also, use promo code CANDY10 and enjoy 10% OFF your entire order!  

Canel’s Caramel Coconut Rolls

Canel’s Caramel Coconut Rolls come in a 1lb resealable bag and feature a rare combination of caramel and coconut flavors. These individually-wrapped, bite-sized candies are perfect for snacking, sharing, or filling candy jars. These rich, creamy-tasting coconut caramel candies are available here at Candy Retailer and can be yours for $5. Each bag comes with roughly 60 pieces, giving you plenty to pass around, or not. To experience these coconut rolls yourself, click below and scoop up a bag today, and enjoy some of the best caramel candy ever made!   

Caramello Candy Bars

It goes without debate, no list featuring the best caramel candies would or could be complete without mentioning Caramello! As one of America’s favorite caramel-chocolate candy bars, we now carry both king-size and original-size 18-count boxes, perfect for those who already know this is one of the best candy bars ever made! Sure, there are many other notable caramel candy bars worth mentioning, such as Twix and Milky Way, but let’s be honest here, nothing quite hits like a Caramello candy bar, not even Rolo! But then again, that’s only my opinion, which you can read more about here if interested. 

Eiffel Caramel Bon Bons

Next up, we have Eiffel Caramel Bon Bons! Although they’re not as soft and gooey as some other caramel candies on this list, they’re still bite-sized, caramel-flavored, chewy candies that millions of people love in the US and around the world. You can buy them here at Candy Retailer in a 4oz bag for under $5, which is a steal if you ask me! If you know, you know. Unfortunately, these don’t get a lot of marketing, making them a brand rarely known by younger people, but we plan to change that today! So, if that’s you, scoop up a bag of Bon Bons below and try something new, at the same time, something old and original. 

Goetzes Caramel Cow Tales

As one of the best caramel candy brands sold in the USA, Goetzes Caramel Cow Tales are a top choice among those who truly love caramel candy! I can’t speak for everyone, but I’ve always loved Cow Tales, especially Caramel Brownie Cow Tales, those are in a league of their own if you ask me! However, I also like caramel apple, strawberry, and honey bun, all of which you can find here at Candy Retailer! We offer 36-count boxes, with or without a collector’s tumbler, and original Cow Tales Minis, which come in a 90-count tub, so we have it all. Click below to see current prices and availability. 

Goetze’s Caramel Creams

Once again, Goetze’s makes our list of caramel candies with their iconic Caramel Creams, another favorite according to millions of Americans nationwide! We carry several package sizes, but our $15/ 100ct tub is our best-selling! Made in Baltimore, Maryland, Goetze’s is a caramel candy brand generating over $25 million in annual revenue, so it’s safe to say that people really love and support this brand, which is why no caramel candy list would be complete or accurate without mentioning Goetze’s caramel candies. Who else loves Caramel Creams? 

Sugar Daddy Milk Caramel

Owned by Tootsie Roll Industries, Sugar Daddy and Sugar Babies Milk Caramel candies are still one of the most sought-after caramel candies sold in the United States! However, with a $3 billion brand like Tootsie behind the scenes, Sugar Daddy/ Babies enjoy nationwide marketing, meaning you can find them just about anywhere! So, if you love this iconic, soft & chewy caramel candy, then check out all our package options below, we have single 5oz movie theater candy boxes, bulk-size 24ct boxes, and more! 

Taffy Delight Caramel Salt Water Taffy

If you’re a fan of our content, chances are you know I’m a huge fan of Taffy Delight Salt Water Taffy, including their soft, creamy caramel taffy, which comes in five different flavor options, such as caramel swirls, caramel apple, gourmet caramel (my favorite), caramel corn, and chocolate caramel mocha! Here’s a list of my favorite flavors. This brand is also gluten-free, peanut-free, and kosher, and is exclusively available here at Candy Retailer in a 16oz resealable container (approx. 65 individually wrapped pieces) for roughly $12 a jar! So, if you love Salt Water Taffy and caramel candy, you highly recommend checking out this brand below. 

Tootsie Caramel Apple Pops

As mentioned previously, Tootsie is a $3 billion empire known for making some of the best candy brands sold in the world, especially here in the USA. Aside from their Midgees, Tootsie Pops are their 2nd best-selling product, which also includes caramel apple pops, making them another top caramel candy product sold here at Candy Retailer! I don’t eat them as much as I did when I was younger, but the taste of a caramel apple pop will never fade away! You can get a 48-count box below for under $14, so if this is your favorite, today’s your lucky day! 

Werther’s Original Caramel Candies

Made by August Storck KG since 1903, Werther’s Original Caramel Candies are my favorite! Known for their iconic creamy, nostalgic caramel flavor, this brand now offers several options, including traditional hard candies (original), chewy caramels, caramel apple-filled, caramel coffee, soft caramels, cinnamon creme (limited edition), and salted caramel creme, which is one of the brand’s newest caramel candy flavors, and it’s a keeper! We offer all options, as well as several different package sizes, so if you love this brand, there’s definitely something here for you! Click below for current prices on all bags of Werther’s Original Caramel Candies here at Candy Retailer! 

Zachary Caramel Candy Corn 

Available by the pound, Zachary Caramel Candy Corn is a must-try for anyone who loves this candy combo, and I’m talking about candy corn and caramel candy flavor! Unfortunately, not too many know of Zachary Candies, unless they’re from the Midwest, which is where this Indiana-based candy brand manufactures its candy, including its iconic candy corn, which comes in many flavors, as well as caramel apple! However, it’s their original caramel corn that really stands out here at Candy Retailer! Not only is it highly rated, but it’s also affordable, as you can score a 1lb bag for about $5, making it one of our best-selling caramel candy brands! 

What Is Your Favorite Caramel Candy?

We understand and acknowledge that not everyone’s favorite caramel candy was listed above, nor did we list all options available in our candy store. Our goal was to only offer a sneak peek into our caramel candy collection here at Candy Retailer. We also admit that we don’t have every type or brand of caramel candy in the world, but we’re always open to discovering new candies! So, if you know of a brand or product not listed or available in our store, please share with us in the comments below, so that we can look into getting our hands on some! As a friendly reminder, if you choose to buy from us, don’t forget to use promo code CANDY10 at checkout. Once you do, we’ll automatically apply a 10% OFF discount on your entire order, so make sure you stock up, as the more you buy, the more you save!