Last updated 6 hours ago | Originally Published: November 26, 2024

Chocolate-covered cherries are a favorite among those who appreciate this sweet combination. Known for their juicy, fruity centers and smooth chocolate coating, these candies are incredibly trendy during holidays! They’re also an excellent gift option as well. People often search for the best brands for superior flavor, quality, and consistency. Shoppers typically seek chocolate-covered cherries that offer high-quality ingredients, such as fresh cherries and premium chocolate, along with consistent texture and flavor. This list focuses on the top 10 chocolate-covered cherries Americans prefer based on reputation, reviews, craftsmanship, and overall customer satisfaction.

1. Cella’s Chocolate Covered Cherries

Established in 1864, Cella’s has a long-standing history of producing chocolate-covered cherries. Acquired by Tootsie Roll Industries in 1985, the brand offers cherries enrobed in milk or dark chocolate, each featuring a 100% liquid center. This distinctive feature sets Cella’s apart, providing a unique texture and flavor experience. Their products are available in various packaging options, including gift boxes and bulk quantities, catering to individual consumers and larger gatherings. 

2. Godiva Chocolate Covered Cherries

Godiva, a Belgian chocolatier founded in 1926, is renowned for its premium chocolates. Their Cherry Cordials consist of whole cherries immersed in sweet liquid fondant encased in rich dark chocolate. Available in gift boxes of varying sizes, these cordials are often presented in elegant packaging, making them suitable for special occasions and gifting. Godiva’s commitment to quality ingredients and craftsmanship is evident in their cherry cordials and certified kosher dairy. 

3. Queen Anne Chocolate Covered Cordial Cherries

Since 1948, Queen Anne has been producing cordial cherries, becoming the leading brand in the U.S. Each piece features a whole maraschino cherry suspended in a creamy center, enrobed in either milk or dark chocolate. Queen Anne offers various flavors, including French Vanilla and Cherry Cola, catering to diverse tastes. Their products are available in multiple packages, from small gift boxes to larger assortments, suitable for personal indulgence or sharing during holidays.

4. Orchard Valley Harvest Dark Chocolate Dipped Cherries

Orchard Valley Harvest specializes in producing snacks made from simple, high-quality ingredients. Their Dark Chocolate Dipped Cherries feature real sweetened cherries in 64% cacao dark chocolate. These treats are gluten-free, non-GMO project-verified, and free from artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives. Packaged in resealable bags, they offer a convenient and wholesome snacking option for those seeking a balance between indulgence and natural ingredients. 

5. Green Jay Gourmet Milk Chocolate Cherries

Green Jay Gourmet is known for its handcrafted confections, emphasizing freshness and quality. Their Milk Chocolate Cherries are made with fresh cherries from Michigan, coated in rich milk chocolate. Packaged in resealable bags, these treats are suitable for gifting or personal enjoyment. Green Jay Gourmet focuses on creating products that highlight the natural flavors of their ingredients, appealing to consumers who appreciate artisanal sweets. 

6. Anthony Thomas Chocolate Covered Cherries

Anthony Thomas, a family-owned chocolatier based in Columbus, Ohio, has been crafting confections since 1952. Their Chocolate Covered Cherries, or Cherry Cordials, feature maraschino cherries enrobed in specially blended milk or dark chocolate. Each cherry is individually wrapped for freshness and presented in boxes of approximately 32 pieces, making them suitable for gifting or sharing. Anthony Thomas has received multiple awards for quality and taste, reflecting their commitment to traditional candy-making techniques.

7. Harry & David Chocolate Covered Cherries

Harry & David, established in 1934, is renowned for its gourmet gifts and premium confections. Their Chocolate-Covered Cherries feature sun-ripened, dried cherries enrobed in either creamy milk or rich dark chocolate, finished with a sweet candy coating. These treats are available in various packaging options, including gift boxes and baskets, making them suitable for special occasions or personal enjoyment. Harry & David emphasizes quality ingredients and craftsmanship in its products. 

8. Cherry Bay Orchards Dark Chocolate Covered Cherries

Cherry Bay Orchards, based in Michigan, is a leading producer of Montmorency tart cherries. Their Dark Chocolate Covered Cherries are dried tart cherries coated in rich dark chocolate. These treats are preservative-free, with no added colors, and are certified kosher. Available in various packaging sizes, including bulk options, they cater to individual consumers and larger gatherings. Cherry Bay Orchards focuses on delivering natural and high-quality cherry products. 

9. Cherry Republic Chocolate Covered Cherries

Cherry Republic, founded in 1989 in Michigan, specializes in cherry-based products. Their Chocolate-Covered Cherries feature dried cherries coated in milk, dark, or white chocolate. These confections are available in different packaging sizes, including gift boxes and resealable bags, suitable for gifting or personal enjoyment. Cherry Republic emphasizes the use of locally sourced cherries and high-quality chocolate in its products. 

10. Marich Chocolate Cherries

Marich Confectionery, a family-owned company established in 1983, produces artisan chocolates. Their Chocolate Cherries consist of dried Bing cherries coated in milk and dark chocolate layers. These treats are available in various packaging options, including gift boxes and resealable bags, catering to different occasions and preferences. Marich focuses on combining traditional candy-making techniques with innovative flavors and high-quality ingredients.

America’s #1 Favorite Chocolate Covered Cherries

Cella’s Chocolate Covered Cherries have solidified their position as America’s #1 chocolate-covered cherries through decades of exceptional quality and consumer loyalty. The brand’s signature use of whole cherries with a 100% liquid center encased in premium chocolate creates a unique experience that can’t be duplicated. With over 150 years of history, Cella’s has built trust and nostalgia, becoming a household favorite for holidays and special occasions, making it an all-American candy brand. 

Furthermore, statistical insights show that Cella’s consistently outpaces competitors in consumer preference. Surveys and reviews highlight its superior taste and texture, with many considering it the gold standard of chocolate-covered cherries. Their long-standing reputation for consistent quality and dedication to innovation has kept them at the forefront of consumer choice. The combination of heritage, craftsmanship, and consistent flavor has repeatedly proven why Cella’s remains the leader in this category, and here at Candy Retailer, we couldn’t agree more with this statement. Below is a complete list of Cella’s products in our candy store.

What’s Your Favorite Chocolate-Covered Cherry?

Chocolate-covered cherries are a delicious treat loved by millions of Americans just like you! So, do you have a favorite brand or a specific type you always go for? We’d love to hear your recommendations or any special memories you have about enjoying them. Share your favorites in the comments below, and as a thank-you for joining the conversation, we’ll send you a 10% discount code for your next order!

About Candy Retailer

Candy Retailer offers a wide variety of candy, including an amazing selection of chocolate-covered cherries. With over 15,000 candy and snack products in stock, we have something for everyone, from timeless favorites to unique finds that you can only find here in our store. We focus on quality and freshness, partnering with top manufacturers to deliver only the best to our customers. Our website is easy to use, and with fast shipping, you can enjoy your candy in no time! Follow us on Facebook, where we share daily candy news, new product releases, and deals!

Candy Retailer Logo