Last updated 1 week ago | Originally Published: November 10, 2024
Based on key metrics such as popularity, positive customer reviews, and sales revenue, we compiled the most accurate list of America’s favorite chocolate candies. Then, we compared our findings to our in-house data here at Candy Retailer to confirm, and we agreed—these are indeed America’s favorite chocolate candies! However, on a personal note, many of you may agree or disagree, including us! The truth is that the best chocolate candies are to be determined by individual opinions, not facts. That said, we were surprised to find a few brands made this list; nonetheless, the people have spoken, and the majority agree that these are the best chocolate-flavored candies in the USA, but we’ll let you set the record straight in the comments below!
1. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
Introduced in 1928, Reese’s has become the gold standard in combining peanut butter and chocolate, winning the hearts and opinions of millions with its signature flavor and texture. In fact, Reese’s enjoys massive popularity, with over 42 million fans in the US alone! Furthermore, this chocolate candy brand offers seasonal shapes and limited-edition flavors, making Reese’s a consistent favorite year-round. As one of our best-sellers in our candy store, this list wouldn’t be incomplete without Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups holding the #1 spot.
2. M&M’s
Launched in 1941, M&M’s quickly became an all-American favorite with its colorful, signature candy-coated shells. Available in flavors like plain, peanut, and almond, M&M’s are a top pick almost every time, especially in the United States and here at Candy Retailer! This iconic brand also releases limited-time seasonal colors and flavors that add excitement to its yearly lineup! Plus, M&M’s come in several package options, from single-sized packs to large 1lb jars, making them America’s most sharable and best-selling candy!
3. Hershey’s Kisses
Debuting in 1907, Hershey’s Kisses has become iconic with its foil-wrapped, bite-sized shape that symbolizes joy and sharing! Known for their smooth, creamy chocolate flavor, Kisses are a fixture in candy dishes across America and beyond. The brand offers seasonal flavors and festive wrappings that keep them fresh and appealing in the eyes of fans! Here at Candy Retailer, you will discover a forever-growing selection of Hershey Kisses year-round, especially during the holidays! So, if this is your favorite chocolate candy, click below to own the moment.
4. Rolo
Introduced in 1937, Rolo blends smooth milk chocolate with a gooey caramel center, creating a satisfying experience that offers an unforgettable, one-of-a-kind flavor unlike anything else! Not to mention, its signature roll design makes this chocolate candy easy to share or to enjoy solo. Either way, Rolo is a popular choice due to its distinct caramel-chocolate combination, making it a timeless favorite among those who know! As for those who don’t know, now’s the time to discover what makes this brand one of the best chocolate candies in America!
5. Milk Duds
A classic since 1928, Milk Duds feature chewy caramel covered in a milk chocolate coating. Known for their iconic yellow theater-style candy box, Milk Duds have become a go-to brand for moviegoers seeking a chocolate candy that lasts until the ending credits. With a thick, chewy texture and sweet caramel flavor center, Mil Duds have maintained their appeal over decades, making them a top pick for candy lovers who enjoy a satisfying, longer-lasting chocolate candy experience! Order here at Candy Retailer to make movie night that much sweeter!
6. Junior Mints
Since 1949, Junior Mints has offered a refreshing combination of dark chocolate and creamy mint filling, providing a unique alternative to other chocolate candies. These bite-sized, cool treats also come in a theater-style box, making them a popular movie candy nationwide! The crisp, mint-chocolate flavor has earned Junior Mints a loyal fan base, especially among America’s most dedicated movie-goers! To enjoy Junior Mints when you want, pick up a few boxes here at Candy Retailer and never have a boring movie night at home again!
7. Whoppers
Introduced in 1949, Whoppers are America’s #1 favorite malt chocolate candy brand, especially among movie-goers! Often found in a classic 5oz theater box, Whoppers are a nostalgic candy favorite, appreciated for their crispy, airy texture. Known for its unmistakable flavor, these crunchy chocolate-covered malt balls have earned a lasting place in the hearts of candy fans nationwide! Popular in every cinema in the country, this band stood against the test of time and won! Click below to see all our package options here at Candy Retailer and make them yours!
8. Sixlets
Introduced in 1960, Sixlets are tiny, round chocolate-flavored candies with a crunchy candy shell that offers a sweet, easy-to-eat treat. Known for their vibrant colors, Sixlets have a light, sweet chocolate taste, making them an instant hit with whoever tries them for the first time! Their colorful appearance and unique candy coating are perfect for snacking and a cheerful option for anyone seeking a quick, playful candy mix. Frankly, we were surprised to see this brand make the list, but after confirming the numbers, Sixlets is definitely one of the best-selling chocolate candy brands in America, and that’s a fact.
9. Raisinets
Released in 1927, Raisinets makes the best chocolate-covered raisins in America! This iconic, all-American brand is sold in familiar theater-style boxes and appeals to those seeking authentic candy made with premium chocolate and natural, whole-fruit California raisins! Plus, this iconic brand doesn’t use artificial flavors or colors! So, if you love milk chocolate-covered raisins, then chances are you Raisinets! If that’s you, click below and order here at Candy Retailer!
10. Goobers
Goobers offer a simple, satisfying blend of crunchy, dry-roasted peanuts coated in smooth, rich milk chocolate. Known for its theater box packaging, this brand is a top choice among moviegoers craving a classic sweet and salty candy vibe. Like others on our list, this brand is another traditional theater candy you can purchase here at Candy Retailer! Furthermore, this is another brand we didn’t expect to make the list, but according to statistics and our recent sales, Goobers have once again proven to be one of America’s favorite chocolate candies!
What Is Your Favorite Chocolate Candy?
With our list now published, we know our top picks might spark some debate, and that’s totally fine; we love a good candy debate here at Candy Retailer, but at the end of the day, it’s all love! That said, our list is based on customer opinions and reviews, which we compared to sales data to confirm or reject, and according to our findings, these are America’s favorite chocolate candies that aren’t candy bars! So, let’s hear your favorites! Represent your brand(s) in the comments below, and we’ll send you a 10% OFF discount code to use on anything in our store! We have over 15,000 snack and candy products, including one of the country’s most extensive chocolate candy selections, so we’re confident you’ll find something here that speaks to your heart. Thanks for reading; we look forward to hearing from you!
Recent Comments