15 Caramel Candy Brands Americans Love the Most

Werther’s Original Hard Caramels are classic, buttery candies with a firm texture and a rich caramel flavor. Made from real cream, butter, and a hint of vanilla, they offer a slow-melting experience that has remained popular for generations. These candies come individually wrapped conveniently and are available in various package sizes, appealing to a wide audience. Known for consistency in taste and texture, we carry all of Werther’s candy flavors and package options. Click below to view our entire inventory and take the moment to own it.

Werther’s Original Soft Caramels offer a softer alternative to the brand’s hard candies, blending caramel flavor with a creamy, chewy consistency. Made with a mix of real butter and cream, these candies deliver the signature Werther’s taste but are soft and chewy instead of hard. Individually wrapped for easy sharing, these caramels are packaged in resealable bags for freshness and easy storage. So, if you prefer chewy caramel over hard, click below to see all our options and never settle for less!

Goetze’s Caramel Creams, also known as “Bulls-Eyes,” are unique caramel candies with a soft, chewy exterior and a sweet cream center. Introduced in the early 1900s, they offer a nostalgic candy experience with a balanced blend of caramel and creamy filling. Each piece is individually wrapped for freshness and convenience. Caramel Creams aren’t an easy find; however, that’s never the case here at Candy Retailer! So, if you love Goetze’s caramel candies as much as we do, then check out our inventory; we carry them all.

Sugar Daddy is a classic caramel lollipop enjoyed since the 1920s. Known for its long-lasting, firm caramel, it provides a rich, slow-melting experience. The candy is made from a blend of sugar and milk, creating a thick texture that requires a little time to enjoy; if you know, you know! Available in multiple sizes, from mini to jumbo, Sugar Daddy remains a popular choice for those looking for nostalgic, traditional caramel candy on a stick. So, if that’s you, click the ‘Buy Now’ button below and go crazy!

Sugar Babies are small, bite-sized caramel candies with a soft, chewy texture and a sweet, buttery flavor; you know the stuff. Developed as a spin-off of the Sugar Daddy lollipop, these candies come coated with a candy shell, which adds a slight crunch before reaching the caramel center. Sugar Babies are commonly sold in theater-style boxes, making them a popular choice for movie nights and candy lovers seeking a convenient, shareable caramel candy! To purchase your favorite caramel candy brand, click below to make them yours!

Slo Poke Caramel Candy is a favorite known for its dense, chewy texture and deep flavor. Originally available as a lollipop, Slo Poke was reimagined as individually wrapped bite-sized pieces for easy snacking and sharing. Made from simple ingredients, this candy offers a long-lasting chew, allowing fans to savor its authentic caramel taste just the way you love it. If that’s you or somebody new to original, all-American candy, click below and enjoy simpler times, not to mention one of our favorite caramel candies of all time!

Brach’s Chewy Caramels are individually wrapped, soft caramel candies known for their smooth, creamy texture and rich, buttery flavor. Made with real milk, these candies offer a satisfying chew that has appealed to caramel lovers for decades. They come in various packaging sizes, making them suitable for snacking, baking, or sharing. Brach’s Caramels are famous for their consistent quality and nostalgic taste, making them America’s most popular caramel candy brand. Also, Nips Caramels are now Brach’s, just for those who didn’t know!

Zachary Caramel Candy Corn combines classic candy corn with a caramel twist. These bite-sized, triangular candies feature a caramel coating that adds an authentic, smooth taste to the traditional candy corn sweetness; we’re sure you can imagine! These candies are often enjoyed during the fall season and are popular for seasonal decorations, such as candy dishes. Zachary Candy isn’t always easy to find; however, when you shop here at America’s favorite candy store, you’ll never leave disappointed.

Primrose Dairy Rich Caramels are traditional caramel candies with a creamy, melt-in-your-mouth texture. Made using a classic recipe with ingredients like real cream and butter, they offer a smooth, rich caramel flavor. Each piece is individually wrapped, making them convenient for on-the-go enjoyment. Primrose Dairy Rich Caramels are often favored for their quality ingredients and consistent, nostalgic taste, appealing to caramel fans seeking a classic candy experience.

Taffy Delight Gourmet Caramel Salt Water Taffy has a soft, stretchy texture and a rich caramel flavor, unlike anything on our list. Each piece is individually wrapped and made to offer a smooth, chewy experience with a balanced caramel taste that hits the spot every time! Known for quality ingredients and a gourmet touch, these taffies are popular in gift baskets and specialty candy collections. Plus, they’re gluten-free and kosher-certified, making them suitable for millions of saltwater taffy lovers; could that be you?

Dove Caramel Promises are individually wrapped milk chocolates filled with a smooth, creamy caramel center. The outer chocolate shell has a rich, velvety texture, while the caramel filling provides a soft, indulgent experience. Packaged in resealable bags, Dove Promises are often chosen for sharing or gifting. Known for premium ingredients, these caramel-filled chocolates almost didn’t make the list because they’re not 100% caramel candy; nonetheless, they’re just too good to ignore! To find out how good they really are, click below and give them a try!

Eiffel Caramel Bon Bons are French-inspired caramel candies with a firm, chewy texture and a mildly sweet caramel flavor. Often found in specialty candy shops, these bonbons are known for their unique shape and distinctive taste. Each piece is individually wrapped, making it convenient for on-the-go snacking and sharing. Eiffel Bon Bons appeals to those looking for an international caramel candy experience with a hint of French tradition. So, if that’s you, bonjour, amateurs de bonbons, bienvenue chez Candy Retailer! Click below to own.

Caramel Cow Tales are long, caramel candy sticks with a soft, chewy texture and a creamy vanilla center. Created by Goetze’s, these candies are a variation of their popular Caramel Creams, offering the same flavor, just in a different shape. However, Caramel Cows come in many different flavors, so they’re different in their own way! Each piece is individually wrapped, making them convenient for snacking and, of course, sharing! To view all flavors and to make them yours, click below and let us know where to send them!

Taffy Town Caramel Corn is a unique blend of caramel flavor infused into soft, chewy, taffy pieces rather than traditional popcorn. These individually wrapped pieces are known for their smooth texture and authentic caramel taste. Unlike regular caramel corn, Taffy Town’s version provides the caramel flavor without the crunch, appealing to fans of soft, flavorful taffy. We offer this classic caramel candy here at Candy Retailer in 1lb bags (approx. 65 pieces). To make it yours, click the button below and seal the deal.

Wrapples Caramel Apple Wraps are thin sheets of soft caramel designed to wrap around fresh apples for a quick caramel apple treat. Each pack contains individually wrapped caramel sheets, making it easy to make classic caramel apples at home. These wraps are convenient for parties, seasonal treats, and family activities. Wrapples are popular during the fall season and offer a simple, mess-free way to enjoy caramel apples without making caramel from scratch. Now available here at Candy Retailer; click below and bring it home!