Top 10 Best Butterscotch Candy Brands In America

Arcor, established in Argentina in 1951, is a globally recognized leader in the confectionery industry, known for producing high-quality sweets. Their Sugar-Free Butterscotch Discs are classic hard candies with a deep, buttery flavor, the one you know and appreciate. Our 1lb package comes with approximately 75 individually wrapped pieces, convenient for sharing or personal enjoyment. Arcor’s commitment to consistency and flavor has made these discs popular for those who appreciate authentic, timeless butterscotch hard candy.

Atkinson Candy Company, founded in 1932 in Lufkin, Texas, is a family-owned American brand celebrated for its traditional confections. Known for creating nostalgic flavors, Atkinson produces its Gemstone Sugar-Free Butterscotch Buttons, which deliver an authentic, buttery taste in a classic hard candy disc. Each 1lb package contains approximately 75 individually wrapped pieces, providing convenience for sharing or personal enjoyment. Atkinson’s focus on consistent quality has made these butterscotch buttons popular among fans of authentic, timeless candy flavors.

Founded in Colombia in 1927, Colombina is a global confectionery leader with a diverse product range. Known for its Butterscotch Buttons, Colombina captures the classic buttery flavor Americans love most. Sold in 1lb bags with about 75 pieces, these buttons are popular among those who enjoy authentic, traditional butterscotch candy. Colombina’s reputation for quality ingredients and timeless flavor profiles has made these butterscotch buttons a consistent choice among candy fans worldwide, especially here in America.

Founded in 1958, Eda specializes in making the best sugar-free hard candies in America. Their butterscotch candy offers the traditional buttery taste, just as you’d expect, even without the sugar! Our 1lb bags contain approximately 75 individually wrapped pieces, making them an excellent candy dish feature. Eda’s commitment to quality ingredients and authentic flavors has established them as a reputable brand among sugar-free candy fans seeking classic flavors with no guilt attached.

Founded in 1927 in Paducah, Kentucky, Gilliam Candy Company is best known for its nostalgic candy sticks. Their Butterscotch Sticks, part of the Old Fashioned Candy collection, provide the original buttery butterscotch taste you know and love! Each stick measures approximately 5 inches and is individually wrapped, with boxes containing 80 pieces. Gilliam’s commitment to classic flavors and traditional candy-making earns them a top spot on our list of America’s best butterscotch candy brands!

Primrose Candy Company, founded in 1928 in Chicago, Illinois, is a family-owned business recognized for its classic hard candies. Their Butterscotch Buttons capture the timeless, buttery taste in a traditional hard candy disc format. Available in 1-pound bags with about 75 pieces, these buttons appeal to butterscotch lovers looking for a simple, straightforward candy that never disappoints, regardless of the year and decade! Known for quality and flavors, Primrose has a strong reputation in the candy industry, so we’re proud to feature them on our list of the best butterscotch candies in the USA!

Established in 1986, Quality Candy Company produces a variety of classic hard candies, including its world-famous Butterscotch Discs. These individually wrapped, authentic candies flawlessly capture this timeless candy flavor. Our 1lb bags come with roughly 75 pieces, making them convenient for sharing, candy dishes, parties, events, or whenever you want one! Known for using high-quality ingredients, Quality Candy has built a reputation for delivering authentic candy experiences that appeal to butterscotch fans seeking the real deal; this is the one!

Founded in 1893, Reed’s is a Chicago-based candy company recognized for its timeless hard candies, especially its Butterscotch Hard Candy. Known for having a smooth, creamy flavor, these candies offer a nostalgic butterscotch experience just the way you love! Our 6.25oz bags include individually wrapped pieces for easy sharing and freshness. Reed’s dedication to traditional candy-making has made their butterscotch a favorite among consumers seeking authentic, old-fashioned candy with a genuine butterscotch taste.

Produced by Sunrise Confections, a branch of Mount Franklin Foods, Sunrise Butterscotch Discs is another top choice here at Candy Retailer. Our 1lb bags come with about 75 individually wrapped pieces, ideal for any candy dish! Sunrise Confections aims to offer quality confections at accessible prices, making these butterscotch discs a popular option among candy lovers who appreciate traditional flavors and dependable quality, especially those looking for a simple, straightforward butterscotch candy!

Taffy Town specializes in soft, chewy saltwater taffy varieties, with their Butterscotch Salt Water Taffy providing a unique take on classic butterscotch flavor. This “oddball” item captures the authentic taste of butterscotch in a whipped, chewy form, offering something new and original. Our 1lb resealable containers include approximately 65 individually wrapped pieces, providing a new twist on butterscotch candy for those who prefer a softer texture while enjoying the classic butterscotch taste you know and appreciate. I love it, and I think you will, too!