Last updated 5 months ago | Originally Published: October 15, 2023

Top 10 Atkinson’s Candies You Must Try Today

Atkinson’s Candy Company has been a staple in the confectionery industry for years, handcrafting a wide range of candies that have delighted taste buds across generations. 

From peanut butter-based treats to peppermint delights, Atkinson’s offers a diverse array of flavors and textures that cater to a broad audience.

But with so many options, how do you know which ones to try? That’s where we come in. This blog aims to guide you through the top 10 best-selling Atkinson’s candies available right here at Candy Retailer. 

It doesn’t matter if you’re a long-time fan looking to revisit some classics or a newcomer eager to find a new favorite; this list has something for everyone.

So, let’s dive in and explore the sweet goodness that Atkinson’s has to offer, shall we?

The Atkinson Candy Phenomenon

Atkinson’s Candy Company has a rich history that dates back to 1932, when it was founded by B.E. Atkinson, Sr., and his wife, Mabel C. Atkinson. 

The company started small, with Basil E. Atkinson making two-day trips to Houston to purchase candy and tobacco, which he then sold to local stores on his return trip. 

Over the years, the company has grown into a nationally recognized manufacturer known for its unique candies, including Chick-O-Stick, Mint Twists, and Rainbow Coconut Bars.

What truly sets Atkinson’s apart is its commitment to handcrafting some of the best peanut butter-based, peppermint, brittle, and caramel candies. 

Their products have found a home in various retail outlets nationwide, including convenience stores, mass retailers, drug stores, and grocery stores. 

This wide distribution speaks volumes about the company’s reputation and the high quality of its products. Atkinson’s has been particularly innovative when it comes to flavors and textures. 

For example, when they decided to sell their peanut butter-filled hard candy covered in toasted coconut outside of Texas, they named it Chick-O-Stick due to another company already having rights to the name Chicken Bones. 

This kind of ingenuity has helped Atkinsons maintain its position as a leader in the candy industry.

So, if you’re looking to satisfy your sweet tooth with something extraordinary, look no further. 

This detailed list will introduce you to the top 10 best-selling Atkinson’s candies at Candy Retailer, ensuring you find a treat that hits all the right notes!

Top 10 Atkinson’s Candies at Candy Retailer

Navigating the candy aisle can be overwhelming, with so many options to choose from. That’s why we’ve curated this list of the top 10 Atkinson’s candies that are not just best-sellers but also customer favorites at Candy Retailer. 

From coconut delights to peanut butter wonders, this list is your ultimate guide to the must-try Atkinson’s candies.

1. Coconut Long Boys

These chewy Coconut Long Boys offer a tropical blend of caramel and coconut flavors. With an average price of $7.39 for a 1lb pack or $19.99 for a 130ct Tub, they’re an affordable way to indulge in a tropical treat. Why wait? Click below and let Coconut Long Boys transport you to a tropical paradise!

2. Chick-O-Stick

Chick-O-Stick is a crunchy, peanut buttery delight coated in toasted coconut. The average price ranges from $5.89 for a 1lb pack to $27.79 for a 24ct Box. Craving a unique crunch? Tap below and make Chick-O-Stick your next go-to snack!

3. Peanut Butter Bars

Peanut Butter Bars are a smooth and rich treat for all peanut butter lovers. They come at an average price of $14.79 for a 160pc Tub or $3.59 for a 3.75oz Sugar-Free Bag. Need a peanut butter fix? Hit the button below and make Peanut Butter Bars your new favorite!

4. Black Cow Chewy Chocolate Caramel

Black Cow offers a delightful blend of chewy chocolate and caramel, making it a two-in-one treat. The average price is $7.59 for a 1lb pack or $27.79 for a 24ct Box. Eager for a chewy chocolate experience? Click below and add Black Cow to your candy collection!

5. Mary Jane Molasses and Peanut Butter

This candy combines the richness of molasses with the creaminess of peanut butter. Priced at an average of $14.79 for a 160ct Jar, it’s a unique flavor combination you won’t want to miss. Intrigued? Tap below and discover the unique blend of Mary Jane Molasses and Peanut Butter!

6. Rainbow Sticks

Rainbow Sticks are a colorful and flavorful treat that brightens up any day. With an average price of $11.49 for a 36ct pack, they offer a burst of flavors in every bite. Ready to add some color to your life? Hit the button below and bring home a pack of Rainbow Sticks!

7. Honeycombed Peanut

While the price and package size for Honeycombed Peanut weren’t provided, this candy offers a unique texture and flavor that sets it apart. Interested in a different kind of crunch? Click below to explore the unique texture of Honeycombed Peanut!

8. Red and White Mint Twists

These minty treats are perfect for freshening up your day. With an average price of $5.39 for a 1lb pack, they’re a cost-effective way to keep your breath fresh. Need a minty pick-me-up? Tap below and stock up on Red and White Mint Twists!

9. Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Bars

For those watching their sugar intake, these bars offer all the peanut butter goodness without the sugar. Priced at an average of $3.59 for a 3.75oz bag, they’re a guilt-free treat. Looking for a healthier option? Hit the button below and try Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Bars today!

10. Slo Poke Chewy Caramel

Slo Poke offers a chewy caramel experience that’s hard to resist. While the price and package size weren’t provided, this candy is a caramel lover’s dream. Ready for a chewy delight? Click below and make Slo Poke Chewy Caramel your next sweet indulgence!

The Unmissable Appeal of Atkinson’s Candies

Each candy on this list brings its own unique flavor profile and texture, making them must-tries for anyone looking to expand their candy horizons. 

From the chewy delight of Black Cow Chewy Chocolate Caramel to the guilt-free pleasure of Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Bars, there’s something for everyone. 

We encourage you to not only try these flavors but also to share your thoughts with us. Your feedback helps us curate the best selection for our customers.

Unlock Flavorful Moments with Atkinson’s Top 10

We’ve walked you through a curated list of the top 10 best-selling Atkinson’s candies available at Candy Retailer. Every option offers a unique taste experience, promising more than just a sugar rush. 

No matter if you’re a fan of classic flavors or eager to try something new, this list is your gateway to a delightful candy experience. You can also get more involved by letting everyone know that Atkinson’s Candy is best by clicking here and sounding off in the comment section!