Last updated 6 hours ago | Originally Published: December 2, 2024
Peanut butter candy bars have long been a top favorite in the United States! Appreciated for their rich, nutty flavor and satisfying texture, these particular candy bars are either made with creamy or crunchy peanut butter and are often combined with other ingredients like chocolate, caramel, nougat, or wafers. This article explores the top 10 peanut butter candy bars in the US, selected sales revenue, product reviews, and consumer popularity! So, if you’re searching for a new brand to try or revisiting a long-time favorite, explore our list of top picks and discover something that makes your heart smile!
1. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups feature a creamy peanut butter filling surrounded by milk chocolate. Introduced in 1928, these cups are manufactured by The Hershey Company and have become a well-known candy in the United States. Produced in multiple sizes and seasonal shapes, these treats offer versatility. Frequently included in baking and dessert recipes, this product remains a significant part of the candy industry while maintaining consistent consumer appeal through its simple yet effective design.
2. Butterfinger
Butterfinger features a crisp, flaky peanut butter core coated in a smooth chocolate layer. Launched by Curtiss Candy Company in 1923 and now produced by Ferrero, this candy bar has a signature crunch. Its recipe includes molasses, sugar, and peanuts, giving it a distinctive flavor profile. Packaged in a bright orange wrapper, this candy bar is widely recognized. It is available in multiple sizes and appeals to snack lovers seeking something crunchy and sweet.
3. 5th Avenue
5th Avenue offers a crunchy peanut butter center enrobed in a rich chocolate coating. Introduced by Luden’s in 1936 and now produced by The Hershey Company, it features a roasted peanut base blended with sugar and molasses for a caramel-like finish. Known for its simplicity, this candy bar remains a popular choice. The packaging highlights its vintage appeal, and the candy bar is available in standard and miniature sizes.
4. Clark Bar
Clark Bar features a crunchy peanut butter center surrounded by a smooth milk chocolate coating. Introduced in 1917 by the D.L. Clark Company, this peanut butter candy bar has a long history in the candy market. Its crispy texture comes from a blend of sugar, corn syrup, and peanut butter. Now produced by Boyer Candy Company, it is available in full-size and bite-size options. This treat is recognized for its iconic red packaging and nostalgic appeal.
5. Zagnut
Zagnut combines a crispy peanut butter center with a toasted coconut coating, offering a unique texture and flavor. Launched in 1930 by the D.L. Clark Company, it stands out as a candy bar without chocolate. Now produced by The Hershey Company, it remains a distinct choice among peanut butter candies. Its retro-inspired packaging and rare combination of ingredients make it a notable product in the confectionery market, particularly in the United States.
6. Snickers Peanut Butter
Snickers Peanut Butter features thick layers of creamy peanut butter, caramel, and nougat covered in milk chocolate. Developed as a variation of the classic Snickers bar, it offers a soft, chewy texture and multi-layered flavor. Manufactured by Mars, Incorporated, it comes in many sizes, including square-shaped portions for easy sharing. Introduced to expand the Snickers product line, this product is now one of the most sought-after peanut butter candy bars in the USA!
7. M&Ms Peanut Butter
Peanut Butter M&Ms features a creamy peanut butter center encased in a colorful candy shell, just as you know and love! Produced by Mars, Incorporated, this product debuted in 1991 as a variation of the classic M&M’s. Each piece combines smooth peanut butter with a thin layer of milk chocolate for added flavor. Offered in many different package sizes, it appeals to individual and group snacking. Its bright, vibrant coating and shape distinguish it from all other peanut butter candy options.
8. Boyer Peanut Butter Cups
Boyer Peanut Butter Cups consist of a thick peanut butter filling covered in milk chocolate. Created in the 1930s by the Boyer Brothers, these cups stand out for their unique ridged design. Packaged in pairs, they offer a hearty, satisfying portion. Manufactured by Boyer Candy Company, they maintain a strong connection to their Pennsylvania roots. This product provides a traditional take on peanut butter and chocolate combinations while honoring its historical significance. For those who’ve never tried these, they’re similar to Reese’s but different in their own original way!
9. Atkinson Peanut Butter Bars
Atkinson Peanut Butter Bars feature a crunchy texture and bold peanut butter flavor. Produced by Atkinson Candy Company, these bars are made with simple ingredients, including roasted peanuts and pure cane sugar. Known for their hard candy-like consistency, they are individually wrapped for convenience. These bars are gluten-free, contain no artificial colors, and are certified kosher, meeting diverse dietary needs. Their distinct combination of crunch and sweetness sets them apart from softer peanut butter candies.
10. Chex Mix Peanut Butter Chocolate Bars
Chex Mix Peanut Butter Chocolate Bars combine Chex cereal with peanut butter and a chocolate coating. Produced by General Mills, these bars include whole grain cereal as a key ingredient. Each individually wrapped bar provides a crunchy texture and a sweet, nutty flavor. Designed for portability, they serve as a convenient snack option for those on the go or those with busy schedules. Suitable for busy lifestyles, these snack bars provide a straightforward solution for curving hunger pains!
11. Fit Crunch Peanut Butter Protein Bars
Fit Crunch Peanut Butter Protein Bars feature three peanut butter varieties: Loaded Peanut Butter Blast, Peanut Butter and Jelly, and Peanut Butter. Each bar includes a protein-rich base, a soft peanut butter layer, and a chocolate coating. Developed by Chef Robert Irvine, these bars deliver 30 grams of protein per serving. Gluten-free and made with quality ingredients, they cater to fitness and dietary needs. Their layered design combines flavor and nutrition, making them the perfect snack for those times when you need an extra boost.
12. Special K Peanut Butter Protein Bars
Special K Peanut Butter Protein Bars feature a soft, chewy texture with a peanut butter core. Produced by Kellogg’s, these bars include added protein and fiber, supporting energy and satiety. Each bar is individually wrapped, making it suitable for quick snacks or meal replacements. They cater to health-conscious consumers with a blend of wholesome ingredients like oats and soy protein. Recognized for their nutritional benefits, these bars are a top pick in the protein snack category.
What’s Your Favorite Peanut Butter Candy Bar?
We’ve listed some of America’s best peanut butter candy bars, but now it’s your turn to weigh in! Share your top picks, a memorable experience, or a go-to choice. From creamy centers to crunchy textures, peanut butter candy bars come in many options that stand out for their flavor and appeal. Add your voice to the discussion and receive a 10% discount code as a thank-you for contributing to the conversation. We value your opinions, and so do our readers!
About Candy Retailer
Candy Retailer specializes in a wide range of candy, including top peanut butter candy bars. The selection features classics like Reese’s and Butterfinger and nostalgic options such as Clark Bar and Zagnut. Located in Newport, Kentucky, products are stored in a climate-controlled facility to ensure freshness. Offering bulk candy, seasonal favorites, and retro treats, the inventory is always growing to meet the needs of candy lovers everywhere. You can also follow us on Facebook for weekly stories, updates, and new product drops!
Recent Comments